08-0611_GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION_Personal Services AgreementPERSONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT is made, entered into, and shall become effective this 11th
day of June, 2008, by and between the City of San Juan Capistrano (hereinafter
referred to as the "City") and Government Finance Officers Association (hereinafter
referred to as the "Consultant").
RECITALS:
WHEREAS, City desires to retain the services of Consultant regarding the City's
proposal for Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning and
WHEREAS, Consultant is qualified by virtue of experience, training, education
and expertise to accomplish such services.
NOW, THEREFORE, City and Consultant mutually agree as follows:
Section 1. Scope of Work.
The scope of work to be performed by the City shall consist of those tasks as set
forth in Exhibit "A - Statement of Work - Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business
Planning City of San Juan Capistrano," and Exhibit "B - GFOA Long -Term Vision and
Strategic Business Plan Proposal for The City of San Juan Capistrano", attached and
incorporated herein by reference; the provisions in Exhibit "A" shall control any conflicts
between provisions in Exhibit "A" and Exhibit "B." To the extent that there are any
conflicts between the provisions described in Exhibit "A" and those provisions contained
within this Agreement, the provisions in this Agreement shall control.
Section 2. Term.
This Agreement shall commence on the effective date and shall terminate when
all services required hereunder shall be completed, no later than May 2009.
Section 3. Compensation.
3.1 Amount.
Total compensation for the services hereunder shall not exceed $102,730
as set forth in Exhibit "C" attached and incorporated herein by reference.
3.2 Method of Payment.
Subject to Section 3.1, Consultant shall submit invoices based upon each
phase of work that has been satisfactorily completed. The amount of each phase
invoice shall be as outlined in Exhibit "C". Invoices shall be paid within 30 days of the
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
City's approval of the deliverables for the related phase of work. A deliverable will be
deemed "satisfactorily completed," and GFOA will invoice the City 1) upon notification of
satisfaction by the City's designed representative; or 2) 30 -days subsequent to the date
GFOA provided the City with the deliverable, whichever comes first. The City may
request one set of revisions to a deliverable within 30 days from the date GFOA sends
the first version of the deliverable. If revisions are requested, the date the phase has
been satisfactorily completed will occur 30days following the date GFOA sends the
revised deliverable to the City.
3.3 Records of Expenses.
Consultant shall keep complete and accurate records of all costs and
expenses incidental to services covered by this Agreement. These records will be
made available at reasonable times to City.
Section 4. Independent Contractor.
It is agreed that Consultant shall act and be an independent contractor and not
an agent or employee of City, and shall obtain no rights to any benefits which accrue to
City's employees.
Section 5. Limitations Upon Subcontracting and Assignment.
The experience, knowledge, capability and reputation of Consultant, its principals
and employees were a substantial inducement for City to enter into this Agreement.
Consultant shall not contract with any other entity to perform the services required
without written approval of the City. This Agreement may not be assigned, voluntarily or
by operation of law, without the prior written approval of the City. If Consultant is
permitted to subcontract any part of this Agreement by City, Consultant shall be
responsible to City for the acts and omissions of its subcontractor as it is for persons
directly employed. Nothing contained in this Agreement shall create any contractual
relationships between any subcontractor and City. All persons engaged in the work will
be considered employees of Consultant. City will deal directly with and will make all
payments to Consultant.
Section 6. Changes to Scope of Work.
For extra work not part of this Agreement, a written authorization from City is
required prior to Consultant undertaking any extra work. In the event of a change in the
Scope of Work provided for in the contract documents as requested by the City, the
Parties hereto shall execute an addendum to this Agreement setting forth with
particularity all terms of the new agreement, including but not limited to any additional
Consultant's fees.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 7. Familiarity with Work and/or Construction Site.
By executing this Agreement, Consultant warrants that: (1) it has investigated
the work to be performed; (2) if applicable, it has investigated the work site(s), and is
aware of all conditions there; and (3) it understands the facilities, difficulties and
restrictions of the work to be performed under this Agreement. Should Consultant
discover any latent or unknown conditions materially differing from those inherent in the
work or as represented by City, it shall immediately inform the City of this and shall not
proceed with further work under this Agreement until written instructions are received
from the City.
Section 8. Time of Essence.
Time is of the essence in the performance of this Agreement.
Section 9. Compliance with Law.
Consultant shall comply with all applicable laws, ordinances, codes and
regulations of federal, state and local government.
Section 10. Conflicts of Interest.
Consultant covenants that it presently has no interest and shall not acquire any
interest, direct or indirect, which would conflict in any manner or degree with the
performance of the services contemplated by this Agreement. No person having such
interest shall be employed by or associated with Consultant.
Section 11. Copies of Work Product.
At the completion of the work, Consultant shall have delivered to City at least one
(1) copy of any final reports and/or notes or drawings containing Consultant's findings,
conclusions, and recommendations with any supporting documentation. All reports
submitted to the City shall be in reproducible format, or in the format otherwise
approved by the City in writing.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 2
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 12. Ownership of Documents.
All reports, information, data and exhibits prepared or assembled by Consultant
in connection with the performance of its services pursuant to this Agreement are
confidential to the extent permitted by law, and Consultant agrees that they shall not be
made available to any individual or organization without prior written consent of the City.
All such reports, information, data, and exhibits shall be the property of the City and
shall be delivered to the City upon demand without additional costs or expense to the
City. The City acknowledges such documents are instruments of Consultant's
professional services. In the course of performance hereunder, Consultant may use
(and may authorize the City's personnel to use) certain Consultant Intellectual Property
to assist in engagement completion. The City shall not have or obtain any right or title
to or interest in such Consultant Intellectual Property (or in any modifications or
enhancements thereto). Consultant makes no express or implied warranties of any kind
regarding the Consultant Intellectual Property.
Section 13. Indemn'
To the fullest extent permitted by law, Consultant agrees to protect, defend, and
hold harmless the City and its elective and appointive boards, officers, agents, and
employees from any and all claims, liabilities, expenses, or damages of any nature,
including attorneys' fees, for injury or death of any person, or damages of any nature,
including interference with use of property, arising out of, or in any way connected with
the negligence, recklessness and/or intentional wrongful conduct of Consultant,
Consultant's agents, officers, employees, subcontractors, or independent contractors
hired by Consultant in the performance of the Agreement. The only exception to
Consultant's responsibility to protect, defend, and hold harmless the City, is due to the
negligence, recklessness and/or wrongful conduct of the City, or any of its elective or
appointive boards, officers, agents, or employees.
Consultant's liability for any matter arising under this Agreement or from any
transaction contemplated herein, including without limitation the provision of the
Services, shall not exceed the actual amount paid by an insurer as a result of any claim
made with respect to such matter under Consultants insurance policies (the "Liability
Cap"). The City acknowledges that the Liability Cap is a material term upon which
Consultant has relied in entering into this Agreement and that Consultant would not
have entered into this Agreement in the absence of such provision.
Section 14. Acceptance and Release
The City shall be deemed to have accepted all Services in a given Phase and the work
product resulting therefrom upon the City's payment of the invoice received from
Consultant in respect of the Services. Upon such acceptance, the City shall be deemed
to have released the Consultant from any additional work under such Phase of the
Services.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 3
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 15. Insurance.
On or before beginning any of the services or work called for by any term of this
Agreement, Consultant, at its own cost and expense, shall carry, maintain for the
duration of the agreement, and provide proof thereof that is acceptable to the City, the
insurance specified below with insurers and under forms of insurance satisfactory in all
respects to the City. Consultant shall not allow any subcontractor to commence work
on any subcontract until all insurance required of the Consultant has also been obtained
for the subcontractor. Insurance required herein shall be provided by Admitted Insurers
in good standing with the State of California and having a minimum Best's Guide Rating
of A- Class VII or better.
15.1 Comprehensive General Liability.
Throughout the term of this Agreement, Consultant shall maintain in full
force and effect Comprehensive General Liability coverage in an amount not less than
one million dollars per occurrence ($1,000,000.00), combined single limit coverage for
risks associated with the work contemplated by this agreement. If a Commercial
General Liability Insurance form or other form with a general aggregate limit is used,
either the general aggregate limit shall apply separately to the work to be performed
under this agreement or the general aggregate limit shall be at least twice the required
occurrence limit.
15.2 Comprehensive Automobile Liability.
Throughout the term of this Agreement, Consultant shall maintain in full
force and effect Comprehensive Automobile Liability coverage, including owned, hired
and non -owned vehicles in an amount not less than one million dollars per occurrence
($1,000,000.00).
15.3 Worker's Compensation.
If Consultant intends to employ employees to perform services under this
Agreement, Consultant shall obtain and maintain, during the term of this Agreement,
Worker's Compensation Employer's Liability Insurance in the statutory amount as
required by state law.
15.4 Proof of Insurance Requirements/Endorsement.
Prior to beginning any work under this Agreement, Consultant shall submit
the insurance certificates, including the deductible or self -retention amount, and an
additional insured endorsement naming City, its officers, employees, agents, and
volunteers as additional insureds as respects each of the following: Liability arising out
of activities performed by or on behalf of Consultant, including the insured's general
supervision of Consultant; products and completed operations of Consultant; premises
owned, occupied or used by Consultant; or automobiles owned, leased, hired, or
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 4
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
borrowed by Consultant. The coverage shall contain no special limitations on the scope
of protection afforded City, its officers, employees, agents, or volunteers.
15.5 Errors and Omissions Coverage
Throughout the term of this Agreement, Consultant shall maintain Errors
and Omissions Coverage (professional liability coverage) in an amount of not less than
One Million Dollars ($1,000,000). Prior to beginning any work under this Agreement,
Consultant shall submit an insurance certificate to the City's General Counsel for
certification that the insurance requirements of this Agreement have been satisfied.
15.6 Notice of Cancellation/Termination of Insurance.
The above policy/policies shall not terminate, nor shall they be cancelled,
nor the coverages reduced, until after thirty (30) days' written notice is given to City,
except that ten (10) days' notice shall be given if there is a cancellation due to failure to
pay a premium.
15.7 Terms of Compensation.
Consultant shall not receive any compensation until all insurance
provisions have been satisfied.
15.8 Notice to Proceed.
Consultant shall not proceed with any work under this Agreement until the
City has issued a written "Notice to Proceed" verifying that Consultant has complied
with all insurance requirements of this Agreement.
Section 16. Termination.
City shall have the right to terminate this Agreement without cause by giving
thirty (30) days' advance written notice of termination to Consultant.
In addition, this Agreement may be terminated by any party for cause by
providing ten (10) days' notice to the other party of a material breach of contract. If the
other party does not cure the breach of contract, then the agreement may be terminated
subsequent to the ten (10) day cure period.
Section 17. Notice.
All notices shall be personally delivered or mailed to the below listed addresses,
or to such other addresses as may be designated by written notice. These addresses
shall be used for delivery of service of process:
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
To City: City of San Juan Capistrano
32400 Paseo Adelanto
San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675
Attn: Cindy Russell
To Consultant: Government Finance Officers Association
203 N LaSalle, Suite 2700
Chicago, Illinois 60601
Attn: Anne Spray Kinney
Section 18. Attorneys' Fees.
If any action at law or in equity is necessary to enforce or interpret the terms of
this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees, costs
and necessary disbursements in addition to any other relief to which he may be entitled.
Section 19. Dispute Resolution.
In the event of a dispute arising between the parties regarding performance or
interpretation of this Agreement, the dispute shall be resolved by binding arbitration
under the auspices of the Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Service ("JAMS").
Section 20. Publications
As an educational, nonprofit, professional membership association, Consultant
reserves the right to publish non -confidential documents describing the results of, or
created during, the Services performed under this Agreement. Consultant will not
publish any item with the name of the City without obtaining the prior written consent of
the City.
Section 21. Entire Agreement.
This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding and agreement between the
parties and supersedes all previous negotiations between them pertaining to the subject
matter thereof.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement.
CITY OF SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO
By:
Dave Adams, City Manager
GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
By: &fyt fic Lo
Eft2gRKA MOLLO b"A. MAIW677k6'
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
P..
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
EXHIBIT "A"
Statement of Work
Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning
City of San Juan Capistrano
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Methodology, Staffing, and Workplan......................................................................10
1.1 The Long Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning Team 10
1.2 The Work Plan 11
ProjectAssumptions..................................................................................................22
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
1. Methodology, Staffing, and Workplan
1.1. The Long Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning
Team
1.1.1. Organizational Chart
Anne Kinney
Strategic & Business
Plan Mar
GFOA Strategic &
Business Plan
--, Financial Plan Mgr
GFOA Financial
Analysts
----------------------------
1.1.2. Duties of Team Members
City of San Juan Capistrano Team Members
1. Strategic Plan Steering Committee
a. Review work product
b. Sponsor project
2. Project Leader
a. Provide resources as needed
b. Enable staff to accomplish tasks
c. Model behaviors needed for successful planning
d. Encourage other team members
3. Project Coordinator
a. Manage day-to-day scheduling and work requirements
4. Financial Staff
a. Participate in financial analysis meetings
b. Gather data
c. Conduct forecasting
d. Conduct analysis
5. Staff for Strategic & Business Plan
a. Complete business plans
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
IV
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
GFOA Team Members:
1. Anne Kinney, Project Manager and Strategic & Business Plan Manager
a. Work with steering committee and project leader on overall project
direction
b. Facilitate meetings
c. Interview stakeholders
d.. Conduct analysis
e. Coordinate tasks related to Strategic Business Plan and performance
measurement
f. Facilitate meetings
g. Interview stakeholders
It. Conduct analysis
Shayne Kavanagh, Financial Planning Manager
a. Coordinate tasks related to financial planning
b. Facilitate meetings
c. Interview stakeholders
d. Conduct analysis
4. David Burna, Facilitation Assistance
a. Assist with focus group facilitation as required
7. Mike Mucha, Lead Strategic/Business Plan Analyst
a. Assist Strategic & Business Plan manager as required
8. Brenda Boyle, Financial Plan Analyst
a. Assist financial plan manager as required
Third -party Team Members:
1. Chris Swanson, founder of Government Finance Research Group
a. MuniCast configuration and data loading
1.2. The Work Tasks
Task # Description
Responsibilities
Designate City Project Leader and
A
Manager; Define project success
A.i
Designate project leader
Assist
Lead
A.ii
Designate project manager
Assist
Lead
Coordinate meeting to establish & clarify
A.iii
project expectations
Assist
Lead
Conduct meeting to establish & clarify
A.iv
project expectations
Lead
Participate
Develop project expectations agreement
A.v
document
Lead
Assist
A.vi
Develop project plan and timeline
Lead
Assist
Informal project expectations agreement
and formal project plan and timeline (in
Deliverable 1A
MS Excel or MS Project)
Lead
Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
1 I
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Establish a Project Steering Team and
Task B
supporting teams
B.i
Designate project Steering Team
Assist
Lead
Develop requirements for team
B.ii
membership
Lead
Assist
B.iii
Write team charter
Lead
Assist
B.iv
Identify supporting teams and structure
Lead
Assist
B.v
Identify supporting team members
Assist
Lead
B.vii
Coordinate meeting to accomplish tasks
Assist
Lead
B.viii
Conduct meeting to accomplish tasks
Lead
Participate
Create Project Steering Team Charter
Deliverable 1B
and develop structure of supporting teams
Lead
Assist
Task C
Community involvement strategy
C.i
Identify primary stakeholders and groups
Assist
Lead
Identify information desired from
CA
stakeholders
Lead
Assist
Identify timing for when information is
C.iii
needed
Lead
Assist
Identify best tools for engaging
C. iv
stakeholders
Lead
Assist
C.v
Implement tools (excepting focus groups)
None
Lead
C.vi
Coordinate meeting to accomplish tasks
Assist
Lead
C.viii
Conduct meeting to accomplish tasks
Lead
Participate
Community involvement strategy
Deliverable 1C
document
Lead
Review
Phase 2. Create Mission/Vision
Task A
Gather stakeholder input
Interview key stakeholders inside City
AJ
government
Lead
Participate
Establish an approach and schedule for
A.ii
conducting surveys and focus groups.
Lead
Assist
Identify key survey objectives and
A.iii
questions
Lead
Assist
Design detailed survey format and
A.iv
conduct survey
None
Lead
A.v
Develop summary of survey results
None
Lead
Summary memo of stakeholder interviews
Deliverable 2A
and fetus-greups
Lead
Review
Task B
Develop preliminary mission/vision
Develop "straw -man" mission/vision
B.i
based on stakeholder interviews
Lead
Assist
Interview key stakeholders outside City
B.ii
government
Lead
Assist
Refine "straw -man" mission/vision for best
fit possible to City, before focus groups
B.iii
are conducted.
Participate
Lead
Deliverable 213
Strawman mission/vision statement
Lead
Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
12
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Task C
Focus Groups
Review background materials related to
previous City planning efforts and to
better understand the San Juan
Capistrano's unique public policy
C.i
environment and culture.
Lead
None
Develop a format, agenda, questions and
other materials to be used in the focus
groups, with the City's input and
C.ii
feedback.
Lead
Participate
Identify the types of participants to be
C.iii
included in the focus groups
Lead
Assist
Recruit individuals for focus groups.
GFOA can give feedback on ideas City
C.iv
has for recruits.
Participate
Lead
Facilitate the focus group sessions and
C.v
record information gathered
Lead
None
Synthesize information gathered into a
format useful for strategic planning
purposes and prepare a written summary
C.vi
of focus group results
Lead
None
Present the results of focus groups held to
the project steering team for feedback and
C.vii
validation
Lead
Participate
Prepare a brief report of the focus group
results for the focus group participants to
C.viii
keep them engaged
Lead
Participate
Deliverable 2C
Results of focus groups report
Lead
Participate
Task D
Mission and Vision Workshop
Design workshop format, agenda,
D.i
structure
Lead
Assist
Coordinate workshop scheduling,
D.ii
logistical support
Assist
Lead
D.iii
Conduct workshop
Lead
Participate
Facilitate deliberation on mission/vision
,D. iv
statement
Lead
Participate
D.v
Articulte mission/vision
Participate
Lead
Record deliberation and mission/vision
D.vi
articulated by City
Lead
None
D.vii
Formally appprove mission/vision
None
Lead
Deliverable 2D
Summary memo of workshop results
Lead
Review
Phase 3. Analysis
Task A
Financial Analysis
AJ
Draft core values for financial sustainablity
Lead
Assist
A.ii
Review and approve core values
None
Lead
Review existing policies, make
suggestions for improvement and for new
A.iii
policies to support core values
Lead
Review
Develop new policy statements, as
A.iv
needed
Assist
Lead
A.v
Approve new and improved policies
None
Lead
A.vi
Provide template for Municast data
Lead
None
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
13
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
collection
A.vii
Collect and clean data for Municast
None
Lead
A.viii
Load data into Municast
Lead
None
Conduct meeting to review major
assumtions and qualitative factors
A.ix
influencing revenue & expenditures
Lead
Participate
Determine how assumptions will be
A.x
expressed in Municast
Lead
Assist
Make forecast. The City will take a lead
role with GFOA's assistance in Municast
configuration and training, revenue &
expenditure assumptions/analysis, and
refining of the model. The City will
A.xi
ultimately make and own the forecast.
Participate
Lead
Determine debt indicators to be used for
A.xii
analysis
Lead
Assist
A.xiii
Provide data on current debt levels
None
Lead
Provide data on likely future capital
A.xiv
projects
None
Lead
Conduct high-level assessment of debt
A.xv
position
Lead
Assist
Identify major imbalances in financial
A.xvi
position
Lead
Assist
Compare mission & vision with existing
plans. Determine financial impact of other
plans (land use, general plan). The City
will take the lead role, especially in
A.xvii
assessing the impact of the land use plan
Assist
Lead
Develop Financial Analysis Report. City
will be actively involved in deciding what
issues to focus on, gathering data, and
A.xv
contributing its own analysis of issues
Lead
Assist
Deliverable 3A
Financial Analysis Report
Lead
Review
Task B
Environmental Analysis
Identify need for additional stakeholder
B.i
interviews
Lead
Assist
Conduct up to four hours of additional
B.ii
interviews
Lead
Participate
B.iii
Conduct additional interviews
None
Lead
Review other City plans and identify any
divergence from these plans that may be
anticipated as a result of this planning
B.iv
process
Lead
None
B.v
Provide "menu" of financial indicators
Lead
None
B.vi
Select indicators
Assist
Lead
B.vii
Identify up to 5 comparable jurisdictions
Lead
Assist
B.viii
Perform comparisons using CAFR data
Lead
None
B. ix
Gather historical data for indicators
None
Lead
B.x
Construct up to ten financial indicators
Lead
Assist
B.xi
Construct additional financial indicators
None
Lead
Summary report of environmental
analyses including recommendations for
Deliverable 3B
financial strategies
Lead
Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
14
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Phase 5. Business Planning & Performance Measurement
Business planning and performance
Task A measurement template development
Develop business planning and
AJ performance measurement templates Lead Review
Begin to develop information required by
A.ii templates Review Lead
Deliverable 5A Deliver templates Lead Review
Busines planning & performance
Task B measurement development
Develop workshop/training format for city
B.i staff Lead Assist
B.ii Conduct workshop Lead Participate
Coordinate workshop and provide
B.iii logistical support Assist Lead
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 15
Two day planning retreat/workshop with
Task A
City staff and City Council
Get early feedback from Project Steering
AJ
Committee on plan elements to date
Participate Lead
A.ii
Create workshop format & presentation
Lead Review
Identify need for and develop other
supporting documentation for workshop.
The City may have a lead role in
developing certain supporting documents.
A.iii
if GFOA and the City agree as such.
Lead Assist
Schedule and coordinate workshop. Invite
A. iv
participants and address other logistics
Assist Lead
A.v
Conduct workshop
Lead Participate
AM
Write summary of workshop
Lead None
Summary memo recapping workshop
Deliverable 4A
issues and conclusions
Lead Review
Task B
Focus Groups
Develop a format, agenda, questions and
other materials to be used in the focus
B.ii
groups
Lead Participate
Facilitate the focus group sessions and
B.v
record information gathered
Lead None
Synthesize information gathered into a
format useful for strategic planning
purposes and prepare a written summary
B.vi
of focus group results
Lead None
Present the results of focus groups held to
the project steering team for feedback and
B.vii
validation
Lead Participate
Prepare a brief report of the focus group
results for the focus group participants to
B.viii
keep them engaged
Lead Participate
Deliverable 4B
Results of focus groups report
Lead Participate
Phase 5. Business Planning & Performance Measurement
Business planning and performance
Task A measurement template development
Develop business planning and
AJ performance measurement templates Lead Review
Begin to develop information required by
A.ii templates Review Lead
Deliverable 5A Deliver templates Lead Review
Busines planning & performance
Task B measurement development
Develop workshop/training format for city
B.i staff Lead Assist
B.ii Conduct workshop Lead Participate
Coordinate workshop and provide
B.iii logistical support Assist Lead
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 15
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
B.iv City staff complete business plans Review Lead
Deliverable 5B Workshop delivered Lead Participate
Task C
Business plan consultation
Provide up to 15 consultant hours to
CA
support business planning
Lead
None
C.ii
Decide how hours are to be used
Assist
Lead
C.iii
Authorize use of hours
None
Lead
Up to 15 hours of consultant support
Deliverable 5C
provided
Lead
None
Phase 6. Drafting the
Plan
Task A
Committee validation
Develop outline for Strategic Business
A.i
Plan
Lead
Assist
Conduct meeting to review progress and
validate direction and Strategic Business
Plan outline and contents of staffs
A.ii
business plans
Lead
Participate
A.iii
Steering committee issues validation
None
Lead
A.iv
Coordinate meeting
Assist
Lead
Deliverable 6A
Outline for Strategic Business Plan
Lead
Review
Task B
Draft Plan
Write and assemble full plan (compile
business plans). The City will need to take
a strong assist role and may lead the
development of certain sections, where
B.i
deeper, hands-on experience is important.
Lead
Assist
Make copies as may be required for
B.ii
distribution to stakeholders
None
Lead
Deliverable 6B
Draft Plan
Lead
Review
Task C
Forecast update and refinement
Determine scenarios and issues arising
through planning process to incorporate
C.i
into forecast
Assist
Lead
Update Municast to incorporate scenarios
CA
and issues
Lead
Assist
C.iii
Update and refine forecasts
Participate
Lead
Deliverable 6C
Municast model updated
Lead
Assist
Task D
Final Plan
Submit plan for review and comment to
D.i
stakeholder groups
Participate
Lead
DA
Modify plan as required
Participate
Lead
Design format for public meeting to review
D.iii
plan
Assist
Lead
Conduct meeting. GFOA will actively
assist in planning the presentation or can
D. iv
lead the presentation
Assist
Lead
D.v
Modify plan as required
Participate
Lead
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
16
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Develop any special publishing format for
business plan, including binding, graphics,
D.vii etc. None Lead
D.viii Print/Publish final business plan None Lead
Deliverable 6D Public Meeting held Assist Lead
Designing link between business plan and
Task A
budget
GFOA will provide approximately 25 hours
B.i
of assistance for this task. Possible
Lead
Assist
B.ii
detailed activities are are below.
Lead
None
Deliverable 88
Responsiblities can vary based on City's
Lead
Review
direction for use of hours. Responsiblities
Task C
and tasks can be finalized as the project
AJ
progresses.
Assist
Lead
A.ii
Review current budget process
Assist
Lead
CJ
Design linkage between major forecast
Assist
Lead
assumptions and budget development
A.iii
assumptions
Assist
Lead
A.iv
Design budget accountability mechanisms
Assist
Lead
A.v
Design budget request process and forms
Assist
Lead
A.vi
Authorize use of hours
None
Lead
A.vii
Implementation of budget links
None
Lead
Deliverable 7A
25 Hours of assistance provided
Lead
None
Phase 8. Documentation
& Wrap -Up
Task A
Project review
Review project with Strategic Plan
AJ
Steering Committee
Lead
Assist
Deliverable 8A
Review conducted
Lead
Assist
Develop on-going Strategic Business Plan
Task B
process
Develop on-going Strategic Business Plan
B.i
process
Lead
Assist
B.ii
Depict process in flow -chart process map
Lead
None
Deliverable 88
Flow -chart process map
Lead
Review
Transition to the Steering Committee for
Task C
implementation
Define committee's responsibility,
accountability, authority, and rescruces
CJ
for implementing the plan
Assist
Lead
Develop charter for Steering Committee's
C.ii
implementation work
Lead
Participate
C.iii
Execution of implementation strategies
None
Lead
Deliverable 8C
Charter for the Steering Committee
Lead
Review
Note that GFOA provides electronic copies of deliverables and other work in Word, Excel,
and/or PDF formats
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
17
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
1.2.1. Deliverable Expectations
Phase 1 — Project Start-up
1 A. Designate a project leader and project manager and define project success. GFOA will help
develop a Project Expectations Agreement (informal) which will be approved by the Project
Leader or other designated City staff. A formal project plan and timeline will also be finalized at
this point.
1 B. Establish a Project Steering Team and supporting teams. GFOA will write a charter to
clarify responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources of the Steering Team and
supporting teams.
1 C. Community Involvement Strategy. GFOA will deliver a community involvement strategy
document that includes a timetable, mechanisms for community involvement and
communication, specific tools and techniques to involve the community, and a strategy to engage
the local media.
Phase 2 — Creating the Mission and Vision
2A. Summary of Stakeholder Input. GFOA will interview key stakeholders both inside and
outside of city government and will produce a summary report of information obtained from
interviews, focus groups, and other stakeholder input mechanisms the City chooses to use (e.g.,
telephone surveys).
2B. Straw man mission/vision. GFOA and the City will develop a "straw man" mission vision
that can be presented to participants in public engagement forums, particularly focus groups.
The intent is to provide the participants with a starting point and something to react to.
2C. Results of focus groups report. This is a brief report to describe the results of the focus
groups. The report will provide a more direct recounting of the focus groups' input as well as
broader themes synthesized from GFOA's overview of all of the groups.
2D. Mission and Vision Workshop Summary Memo. GFOA will facilitate a public workshop to
present stakeholder input and develop a mission and vision statement. GFOA will provide a
format, supporting tools, and a brief memo of results. The City has the lead role in developing a
mission and vision with GFOA support throughout the process.
Phase 3 - Analysis
3A. Financial Analysis Report. GFOA will conduct an analysis of the City's financial situation
and provide the results in a Financial Analysis Report. At minimum, the analysis is to include the
following activities:
Financial policy review
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
18
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Preliminary revenue/expenditure forecasting (the City will begin to load data into the
Municast model and begin developing forecasts as early in the project as possible)
• Debt analysis
• Imbalance analysis
■ Analysis of financial impact on and of existing plans
313. Environmental Analysis Summary. GFOA will work with the City to conduct a
comprehensive environmental analysis to identify the most important issues facing the City of
San Juan Capistrano over a five-, 10-, and 20 -year period. In order to develop this list of issues,
the environmental scan will identify 1) internal strengths and weaknesses, 2) external threats and
opportunities, and 3) community resources the City might take advantage of. GFOA will produce
a brief summary of the environmental analysis that contains key service, financial, and other
issues and the City's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and challenges. This summary will
also document any divergences from existing plans, such as the general plan and the land use
plan.
Phase 4 — Issues and Strategies Validation
4A. Planning Retreat Summary Memo. GFOA will design and conduct a two-day
workshop/retreat to present a draft set of issues as well as preliminary recommendations on
strategies, overall objectives, and a first cut of an action plan. The workshop/retreat will involve
City staff on the first day and City Council members and executives on the second day. GFOA
will design and facilitate the workshops, provide documents, and produce a written summary of
workshop output and outcomes. During the retreat, any divergence from existing plans will be
addressed.
4B. Results of focus groups report. This is a brief report to describe the results of the second set
of focus groups. The report will provide a more direct recounting of the focus groups' input as
well as broader themes synthesized from GFOA's overview of all of the groups.
Phase 5 — Business Planning and Performance Measurement
5A. Business Plan Templates. GFOA will develop and deliver a set of business planning and
performance measurement templates to help City staff develop the information required for a
business plan. The templates will be designed to produce an "issue driven" business plan, rather
than one focused on departments or other functional divisions of the City.
513. Business Planning & Performance Measurement Development Workshop. GFOA will work
with City staff to develop the business plan and performance measures. GFOA's and the City's
objective will be to train staff to create business plans. GFOA will deliver a workshop or other
mechanism for developing business plans, performance measures, and targets. The City has the
lead role in business plan development with GFOA support throughout the process.
5C. Business Plan Consultation. GFOA can make itself available on a per -hour basis to provide
consultation and staff augmentation to the City, as required to support the completion of the
business plan. GFOA will work with the City to support the completion of the business plan for
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 19
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
up to 15 consultant hours.
Phase 6 — Drafting the Strategic Business Plan
6A. Outline for Strategic Business Plan. A meeting will be held with the Strategic Plan Steering
Committee to review the materials and progress made to this point. The Committee's validation
will allow the Strategic Business Plan to be drafted. GFOA will provide a proposed outline for
the Strategic Business Plan and facilitate a meeting to validate direction and Strategic Business
Plan contents.
B. Draft Plan. GFOA and City staff will cooperate to finalize a draft of the Strategic Business
Plan. The Strategic Business Plan will be based on the strategic, operational, and financial
elements produced throughout the project.
C. Municast Model Updated. The information provided through the foregoing phase will enable
the City and GFOA to refine the revenue and expenditure forecast. It is anticipated that the City
will lead this forecast update, but GFOA will advise how to best incorporate new information
into the Municast model. GFOA will update the Municast model to incorporate assumptions
needed for the City to revise the forecast.
D. Public Meeting to Present Plan. After the draft plan is delivered, there will be a review and
comment period followed by a public meeting to present the plan. GFOA will help the City
design the meeting and will participate in the meeting.
Phase 7 — Linking to the Budget Process
7A. 25 hours of Consultation to Design Link between Business Plan and Budget. GFOA will
work with City staff on a process for assuring that the plan becomes the basis for the budget — or,
at minimum, is a critical input to the budgeting process. GFOA will work with City for up to 25
hours to advise on linkages, develop forms, etc.
Phase 8 — Documentation and Wrap -Up
8A. Project Review Conducted. GFOA will review the project with the Strategic Plan Steering
Committee. Taking the time to reflect on the project and identify what aspects of the project the
City wants to save, delete, and change going forward is the first step towards developing an on-
going Strategic Business Planning cycle.
8B. On-going Strategic Business Plan Process Map. GFOA will propose a final on-going
Strategic Business Planning model for the City that can be maintained independent of consultant
support. GFOA will deliver a flow -chart process map to depict the final recommended process,
including the links into the budget process.
8C. Charter for Strategic Plan Steering Committee's Implementation Role. GFOA will help the
Committee transition to plan implementation. GFOA will help the City develop a charter to
define the Committee's responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources for the
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 20
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
implementation of the plan.
1.2.2. Timeline
July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb March
,iase,�r
. Proje4W, irt-uv AW, :-iaa
A. Designate Leader
B. Establish Teams
C. Involvement Strateg
I-ioc MR1
roups1w,-,
C4 iss
I PLA e lik:-M
2 - iloWMun 4-
A. Stakeholder Input
B. Mission & Vision Workshop
Phas0 -A"l is: -
I �1,111 A
A. Financial Analysis
B. Environmental Analysis
�;ilda7 i5o2n�
Phasc =Issues iW"tegieA4V
A. Planning Retreat
WORM,
mug eat
Phase 5 -.Business Perf6im 3�,
A. Templates Developed
B. Plan & Measures Developed
C. Plan Consultation
rPh:�6 6rAT6�thcsW_"
- 4
A. Committee Validation
B. Draft Plan
C. Forecast Update
D. Final Plan
"43 Phase'7 - LinkAn Budgi-t4r_!.";
F
A. Designm� Link
1,Phase 8meufAQ"Wra �,,_,W`�,77,7
A. Project Review
B. On -Going Planning Process
C. Transition to Implementation
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 21
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The Citv of San Juan Capistrano
2. Project Assumptions
2.1. Listing of Project Assumptions
• City staff provides data and participates in interview and other activities requested by GFOA.
• A single point of contact from the City is identified;
• GFOA undertakes no more than the indicated number of on-site trips within the price
included in this proposal.
o Trip #I - Interview stakeholders on defining success and perception of environment,
meet with Strategic Plan Steering Committee, conduct technical planning workshops
(forecasting, environmental modeling, etc.). 3 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #2 — Focus group facilitation #1 — 4 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #3 — Conduct mission workshop, 1 day, 2 consultants
o Trip #4 — Strategic issues retreat, 2 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #5 — Business plan workshop, 2 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #6 — Present draft plan to committee, t day, 2 consultants
o Trip #7 — Present draft plan to public, 1 day, 2 consultants
o Trip #9 — Focus group facilitation #2 — 4 days, 2 consultants
• GFOA's role in the development of a plan is consultative and advisory in nature. The City
will play an important role in data collection, will participate as partners in plan
development, and will make any final decisions on strategy and direction.
• The project scope is not expanded beyond the items listed in the proposal at the proposed
(discounted) price, unless so negotiated with the GFOA.
• As an educational, nonprofit, professional membership association, GFOA reserves the right
to publish non -confidential documents describing the results of, or created during, the
services described in this scope of work. GFOA will not publish any item with the name of
the City of San Juan Capistrano without obtaining prior written consent of the government.
• GFOA is partnering with the Government Finance Research Group to provide the MuniCast
financial analysis and sensitivity analysis system. GFOA's role is not to provide forecasts of
revenue and expenditures on which the City can rely. The City will have responsibility for
collecting data to be included in MuniCast. Data elements include:
o Historic annual revenues, expenditures, other sources and uses, beginning FYI 999-
2000, for all City appropriated funds
o Current year budgeted or estimated (if available) data
o Historic budgeted/estimated fund balances
o Debt service and other liabilities (e.g. retirement, healthcare, etc.)
o Staff positions data for same time period
o Baseline and alternative forecast scenarios, extending out to 2030 (or other fiscal
period indicated by City), to be jointly developed by City and GFOA team
• GFOA develops its reports to be clear and concise. We focus on brevity in order to make our
reports accessible to the public and elected officials.
• GFOA submits deliverables and other documents electronically in Microsoft Word, Excel,
and or PDF formats.
• GFOA is a non-profit membership association made up of members like the City of San Juan
Capistrano, and therefore we have no owners' equity to fall back on. Therefore, GFOA's
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 22
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
liability and indemnification under any agreement reached with the City must be limited to
the extent of fees paid by GFOA's insurance coverage. (Please note that this limitation would
require an amendment to the City's standard Personal Services Agreement.)
• 12 focus groups would be facilitated by GFOA during initial issue identification.
• The same 12 focus groups would be facilitated by GFOA during strategy development.
• Each of the foregoing focus group meetings will take place within a 1 week period so that
GFOA consultants can make one trip to conduct the focus groups.
• The focus groups would last between 2.5 and 3 hours each.
• The City will develop a report after the second set of focus groups to let the focus groups
know how their input impacted the report and to engage them for plan execution.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
23
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
EXHIBIT "B"
THE RESEARCH AND CONSULTING CENTER
GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
January 30, 2008
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
24
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Table of Contents
Section1 - Cover Letter.....................................................................................................26
Section 2 - Background and Approach..............................................................................28
A. GFOA's Understanding of the City's Project...........................................................28
B. Objectives to be Accomplished................................................................................28
C. The Work to be Done................................................................................................29
D. Out -of -Scope Activities............................................................................................35
Section 3 - Timetable/Schedule of Required Tasks...........................................................35
Section4 - Identify the Team............................................................................................36
A. The Proposing Firm.................................................................................................36
B. Contact Information..................................................................................................37
C. Location of the Work................................................................................................37
D. Organization Chart ....................................................................................................37
E. Proposed Team Members..........................................................................................38
Section 5 - Qualifications and Related Experience...........................................................38
A. GFOA's Strategic and Financial Planning Expertise...............................................38
B. Recent Directly Related Experience.........................................................................39
C. Key Personnel...........................................................................................................40
D. Other Public Entities Served.....................................................................................43
Section 6 - Other Information............................................................................................43
A. Optional Services......................................................................................................43
B. About Our Discount..................................................................................................44
C. Key Assumptions......................................................................................................44
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
25
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 1 - Cover Letter
January 30, 2008
Cindy Russell
Assistant City Manager
City of San Juan Capistrano
City Manager's Office
32400 Paseo Adelanto
San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675
Dear Ms. Russell:
The Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) is pleased to present a proposal to assist
the City of San Juan Capistrano with the development of a long-term vision and strategic
business plan. GFOA has significant experience providing these types of consulting services and
we have completed extensive research on best practices in strategic planning, long-term financial
planting, and performance measurement among our 17,500 members.
We are excited about the chance to work with the City of San Juan Capistrano on this project.
The key elements of our proposal include:
• An Integrated Approach to Planning, Goal Setting, and Budgeting. GFOA's
research on best practices is consistent with the City's desire to create a long-term
strategic, financial and operational context for preparing annual budgets, and for using
performance measurement to link the various components of such a system. Our goal for
this project i5 to concurrently work to assure that individual tasks are completed on time
and are of a high quality and also to assure that all the tasks and products, whether short -
or long-term, are faithful to the overall direction that is set in the mission, vision, and
long term strategies that are developed. Our focus throughout the project will be to work
with the City to ask and answer the following questions:
o Strategic: What are the most important "big picture" strategic issues and concerns
facing the City over the long-term?
o Operational: What actions will the City take to address these issues? What is the
schedule for these activities? Who is responsible? How will progress be measured
and accountability maintained?
o Financial: What are the long -run financial implications of the strategic issues and
operational plans? How can the City maintain financial sustainability over the
long -tern?
An Approach that Assures that the Financial Situation is Systematically Addressed.
Too often, organizations prepare strategic plans in virtual isolation from an understanding
of the available financial resources. Elegant strategic plans, strategies, and service targets
may be created, but after the planning process has ended, these organizations then
struggle to fund goals that may already be publicly announced. Using expertise in long-
term financial planning, and leveraging information from our membership base of 17,500
finance professionals, GFOA's approach provides early and equal attention to the
financial situation in planning. GFOA is the leading authority on long-term financial
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
26
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
planning for local government. GFOA published the popular book Financing the Future:
Long -Term Financial Planning for Local Government enclosed with this proposal) and
has provided advice to many of our member governments on this subject. Further, GFOA
staff has authored articles in numerous journals, including Government Finance Review,
Public Management, School Business Affairs, and School Planning and Management,
and has spoken at conferences and training sessions nationwide.
A Long -Term, Implementation -Ready Approach. Our proposal is designed so that
strategies and operational plans are ready to go for the City's next budget while at the
same time enabling the City to carry forward the Strategic Business Planning process
independent of future consultant support. The best plan if not properly implemented is
simply a costly theoretical exercise. Our approach provides for a transition to
implementation, if possible before our engagement has ended, by working with City staff
to design implementation plans and link these plans to the City's budget.
An Inclusive and Consensus -Driven Approach. GFOA believes public participation in
strategic planning is essential. Our approach will engage the community to be real
contributors to the plan at multiple stages of the process. The most powerful means for
implementing a plan is if the stakeholders of the plan strongly support it. A plan
development approach that builds consensus among stakeholders will result in a plan that
garners a wide base of support.
Municast. GFOA will provide the City with the Municast computerized revenue and
expenditure forecasting software system. Municast is a Microsoft Excel -based tool that is
currently in use by over 20 California municipalities. Municast is powerful and easy to
use. The City can learn more about Municast at www.municast.com.
If you have any questions regarding this proposal, please contact either me using the contact
information below, or Shayne Kavanagh, at 312-578-2276 or skavanagh@gfoa.org.
Sincerely,
Ir
Anne Spray Kinney
Director, GFOA Research and Consulting Center
312-977-9700
akinnev(a)gfoa.org
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
27
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 2 - Background and Approach
This section includes: A) Our understanding of the City's project; B) The objectives to be
accomplished; C) The work to be done; and D) Out -of -scope activities.
A. GFOA's Understanding of the City's Project
The City of San Juan Capistrano has begun to transition from a growing city to a more mature,
"built -out" community. The vast majority of available land has been developed (approximately
90% in GFOA's understanding). This means that the City will not be able to count on new
revenue from growth to the extent it did in the past. Also, a number of indicators point to the
United States entering a period of recession or, if not officially a recession, then at minimum an
economic downturn. The City wishes to take steps now to maintain its solid financial position
through its transition to a fully developed community and through economic downturns.
The City has developed a number of long-term plans, such as a redevelopment plans,
water and sewer master plans, and an open space needs assessment. However, the City has
identified the need for an overarching strategic vision and a long-term vision that is aligned with
financial capacity. Therefore, the City has initiated this project to develop a strategic plan that is
supported by a solid long-term financial analysis, detailed implementation strategies, and
performance measures. GFOA terms this a "Strategic Business Plan."
It is our understanding that the City would like the Strategic Business Plan to provide the
context for its annual budget process. Currently, the City's budget process begins in December;
however, the City anticipates that this schedule may change as a result of the work done on this
project.
B. Objectives to be Accomplished
Objective 1: The City has articulated a clear and concise mission and vision for the community
that is consensus -based. (A mission and vision statement will be developed early in the project
so that it can be used as a yardstick and reference point for the remainder of the project.)
Objective 2: The City has created a written Strategic Business Plan that articulates critical
strategic and fiscal issues, includes objectives and strategies for addressing these issues, and
links these to programs, services, and activities related to daily operations and consequently to
the budget process via performance measures that will be used to gauge progress. (The plan will
be based on a comprehensive environmental analysis that includes a thorough financial
situational analysis.)
Objective 3: The City's Strategic Business Plan contains a long-term financial perspective and
provides strategies for maintaining fiscal stability. (The plan includes an assessment of the
city's financial structure, projects revenues and expenditures over the long term, identifies
potential structural and cyclical imbalances, and proposes courses of action for addressing them.)
Objective 4: The City has the appropriate knowledge base, tools, and processes for regularly
reviewing its financial situation, including a financial trend monitoring system and a
computerized financial modeling and forecasting system. (GFOA's approach provides templates
and tools that can be adopted by the City and focuses on working with City staff throughout the
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
28
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
project to provide staff with hands-on experience.)
Objective 5: The City has a performance measurement and management system that supports
the implementation of the strategic, operational, and financial goals and that provides key
indicators of progress so that elected officials, the public, and city managers will be able to track
progress and know how the City is performing.
Objective 6: The project is conducted using an approach that
• Is inclusive and is perceived as such so that the resulting plan has broad community support.
• Involves city staff as partners with consultants so that the planning cycle and system can be
sustained independent of external advisory or consulting support in the future.
C. The Work to be Done
GFOA will work with the City to accomplish the above objectives in eight phases, as is
described in greater detail later in this section. The key written deliverable of this project will be
a "Strategic Business Plan." The Strategic Business Plan will contain the highest priority
strategic issues facing the City, the strategies the City will pursue, and the actions it will take to
address these issues and their financial implications. The process for providing this deliverable
has three essential components:
• Strategic: What are the most important "big picture" strategic issues and concerns facing the
City over the long-term?
• Operational: What actions will the City take to address these issues? What is the schedule
for these activities? Who is responsible? How will progress be measured and accountability
maintained?
• Financial: What are the long -run financial implications of the strategic issues and
operational plans? How can the City maintain financial sustainability over the long-term?
Phase 1 — Project Start-up
Task A. Designate a Project Leader and Project Manager, and Define Project Success.
GFOA's experience is that this type of organization -wide project will require careful
coordination, communication, and cooperation, both between GFOA's team and City staff, as
well as among City agencies. Therefore, we strongly recommend that the City designate a
Project Leader who is committed to a successful project outcome and to addressing the issues
that prompted the City to initiate this project and who has the authority to make decisions
regarding the process. In addition, we recommend that the City identify a Project Manger to
coordinate the project on a day-to-day basis and serve as the City's liaison with the GFOA team.
Finally as part of this first task, GFOA has found that even though the City would execute a
formal contract with GFOA, it is extremely helpful to spend some time at the very beginning
defining and clarifying expectations regarding how the project will be conducted and the results
that the City hopes for and expects, and documenting these expectations so that they can be
referred to, and revised, if necessary, during the course of the project. This will help us to meet
your expectations.
Deliverable: A City -designated Project Leader and Project Manager, and a Project
Expectations Agreement (informal), which would be developed by GFOA and approved by
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
29
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
the Project Leader or other designated City staff. A formal project plan and timeline will
also be finalized at this point.
=> City Role: Coordinate meetings with GFOA, identify Project Leader and Manager, and
identify and agree on expectations for project success.
Task B. Establish a Project Steering Team and supporting teams. GFOA recommends that
the City designate a Project Steering Team (which will also serve as the City's Strategic
Planning Coordinating Team). The team will give feedback and guidance to GFOA and City
staff and provide continuity to carry over into implementation of the Strategic Business Plan.
GFOA will help the City develop requirements for team membership and write a charter to
clarify the Committee's responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources.
The Strategic Business Planning process is also likely to require supporting teams to
work on various issues and tasks associated with constructing a plan. GFOA will work with the
Project Leader and Project Manager to identify teams and advise on the knowledge, skills, and
ability needed by members.
=> Deliverable: Creation of a Project Steering Team and charter, as well as a structure of
supporting teams.
City Role: Coordinate meetings, approve the charter, agree on teams and name team
members.
Task C. Community Involvement Strategy. GFOA and the City will collaborate to develop a
community involvement strategy for the planning process. Community involvement is important
to ensure that planners consider a comprehensive set of issues, not just those identified by
"insiders" and to increase the likelihood of strong community support for the plan. The
community involvement strategy should include a timetable, mechanisms for community
involvement and communication, specific tools and techniques to involve the community, and a
strategy to engage the local media.
=> Deliverable: Community involvement strategy document.
z* City Role: Provide knowledge on the approaches that work best for the San Juan Capistrano
community and approve a process for going forward.
Phase 2 — Creating the Mission and Vision
Task A. Gather Stakeholder Input. GFOA will begin by interviewing key stakeholders, both
inside and outside of city government. City staff may wish to work with GFOA's team on these
interviews. GFOA will also work with the City to establish and approach and schedule for
conducting focus groups and phone surveys of constituents. GFOA's proposal assumes that
GFOA would help design the focus group approach and conduct a small number (no more than
four) of focus groups in cooperation with City staff. GFOA will also work with City staff to
design other stakeholder input opportunities, as identified in the community involvement
strategy.
Please note that because of the cost and intense resource requirement of conducting a
phone survey, GFOA's proposal and price do not include this activity. Because this is not a core
capability of GFOA, we would have needed to include a sub -contractor to provide this service
and also the costs of GFOA administration and supervision of the sub -contract. We believe that
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 30
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
if the City decides a phone survey is essential to the process, having the City directly procure
telephone survey services would provide equal benefit at lower cost. We therefore assume that,
if the City and GFOA agree that phone surveys are needed, the City would contract separately
for this service.
=> Deliverable: A summary of information obtained from interviews, focus groups and other
stakeholder input mechanisms the City chooses to use (e.g., telephone surveys).
=> City Role: Work together with GFOA to: define interviewees, schedule interviews, conduct
interviews (if desired by the City), and conduct focus groups. The City would also contract
for a phone survey if it is decided that one is needed, and conduct other stakeholder input
opportunities that may be identified in the public involvement strategy to be developed.
Task B. Mission and Vision Workshop. The GFOA will facilitate a public workshop to present
stakeholder input and develop a mission and vision statement. The mission and vision articulate
where the City wants to go and what it wants to become over the next five, 10, and 20 years. The
workshop will use consensus -driven techniques.
=> Deliverable: Provide workshop agenda/structure, conduct workshop, provide brief memo of
results.
=> City Role: Provide logistical support and coordination, and participate in
Phase 3 — Analysis
Task A. Financial Analysis. GFOA will conduct an analysis of the City's financial situation, at
minimum to include the following activities:
• Financial policies. GFOA will identify, catalog, and review the city's financial policies with
the assistance of City staff (particularly to identify existing policies).
• Preliminary Revenue/Expenditure Forecasting. GFOA will work with the City to develop
the "first cut" of a 20 -year forecast, based on status -quo assumptions. GFOA proposes to use
the Municast forecasting system.
• Debt Analysis. GFOA will conduct a high-level assessment of the City's current and likely
future debt position based on the City's capital improvement plan and information included
in the City's most recent comprehensive annual financial report.
• Imbalance Analysis. GFOA and City staff will identify potential future imbalances in the
City's financial and recommend strategies for overcoming these imbalances.
=> Deliverable: GFOA will lead the development of these analyses and will provide the results
in a Financial Analysis Report.
City Role: Provide information to GFOA to conduct analysis. Work closely with GFOA to
use the Municast system to make the forecast. Work with GFOA to identify imbalances and
to create mitigating strategies.
Task B. Environmental Analysis. GFOA will work with the City to conduct a comprehensive
environmental analysis to identify the most important issues facing the City of San Juan
Capistrano over a five-, 10-, and 20 -year period. In order to develop this list of issues, the
environmental scan will identify internal strengths and weaknesses and external threats and
opportunities, as well as community resources the City might take advantage of. The following
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 31
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
techniques will be used:
• GFOA will use information gleaned from stakeholder input activities described in Phase 2,
Task A above, and also conduct additional interviews as needed in order to assure broad
stakeholder input that includes, at minimum, the perspectives of City Council members, City
staff, members of boards and commissions, as well as stakeholders outside City government,
such as the business community, overlapping units of governments, citizen groups and
individual citizens.
• We will also review of other City plans such as land -use, redevelopment, and sewer -water
master plans, etc.
• We will conduct comparative analysis of financial condition indicators with other
municipalities (up to five). The comparative analysis will rely on "industry standard"
indicators of financial condition.
• The City and GFOA will construct a "financial trend monitoring system" of indicators to
reveal favorable and unfavorable trends in the financial environment.
=> Deliverable: An brief summary of the environmental analysis that contains key service,
financial, and other issues and the City's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and
challenges. This summary will also provide GFOA's recommendations on strategies the City
might pursue and new master plans that need to be developed in response to an issue.
=:> City Role: Provide information to GFOA to conduct analysis, participate in various analytic
activities, and review and provide feedback on the summary document.
Phase 4 — Issues and Strategies Validation
Task A. Planning Retreat: GFOA will design and conduct a two-day workshop/retreat to
present a draft set of issues, as well as preliminary recommendations on strategies, overall
objectives and a first cut of an action plan, involving City staff on the first day and City Council
members and executives on the second day.
On the first day, in the morning, we will review the Environmental Analysis Report,
validate the report findings, and present preliminary issues, strategies, objectives and the outlines
of an action plan. In the afternoon, City staff will work in groups to validate, revise, and
supplement this information, as well as take the first steps toward creating an action plan that
will later be used as the framework for the operations section of the Strategic Business Plan.
On the second day, GFOA will facilitate a workshop with the City Council and executive
staff. In the morning, GFOA will present information similar to that presented to City staff, with
the exception that this version will include staff input from the first day of the retreat. In the
afternoon we will facilitate a discussion focused on validating, revising, and supplementing the
key elements that will go into a written plan.
=> Deliverable: Documents, workshop facilitation, and presentations as well as retreat design
and a written summary of workshop output and outcomes.
=> City Role: Scheduling, coordination, invitations, and other workshop logistics as well as
participation. Work with GFOA to validate plan elements to date with Strategic Plan Steering
Committee.
Phase 5 — Business Planning and Performance Measurement
Task A. Template Development. Business planning describes implementation plans and
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
32
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
schedules, high-level financial impacts of strategic goals/action-plans, and performance
measures and other mechanisms for monitoring progress on implementing the plan. Business
planning also assesses risks inherent in the proposed course of action and identifies
contingencies. GFOA will develop and deliver a set of business planning and performance
measurement templates for City staff to help City staff develop the information required for a
business plan. The templates will be designed to produce an "issue driven" business plan, rather
than one focused on departments or other functional divisions of the City.
=. Deliverable: Business Plan templates delivered.
=> City Role: Review templates and begin to develop information required by templates in order
to prepare for Task B.
Task B. Business Planning & Performance Measurement Development. GFOA will work
with City staff to develop the business plan and performance measures. GFOA's and the City's
objective will be to train staff to create business plans. Another objective will be to develop a set
of strategic measures that communicates progress on strategic issues to elected officials, staff,
and the public. From these strategic measures, a larger set of operational measures will cascade
down to departmental operations. These operational measures will help departments to relate
their activities to the City's strategic goals and track their progress. City staff will also identify
performance targets based on the measures to help the City gauge its progress towards goals.
=> Deliverable: A workshop or other mechanism for developing business plans, performance
measures and targets.
=> City Role: Logistical support, participation in the process and completion of business plans.
Task C. Business Plan Consultation. It is unlikely that the Business Plan will be totally
complete at the end of the workshop or training sessions. City staff will have to refine and further
develop the plan as a result of what is discussed at the workshop. GFOA can make itself
available on a per -hour basis to provide consultation and staff augmentation to the City, as
required to support the completion of the business plan.
=> Deliverable: GFOA works with City to support the completion of the business plan for up to
15 consultant hours.
City Role: Make final decision on how GFOA's hours are to be used. Complete business
plans.
Phase 6 — Drafting the Strategic Business Plan
Task A. Committee Validation. A meeting will be held with the Strategic Plan Steering
Committee to review the materials and progress made to this point. The Committee's validation
will allow the Strategic Business Plan to be drafted.
=> Deliverable: Proposed outline for Strategic Business Plan provided. Meeting held to validate
direction and Strategic Business Plan contents.
=> City Role: Coordinate meeting, validate Plan contents.
Task B. Draft Plan. GFOA and City staff will cooperate to finalize a draft of the Strategic
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 33
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Business Plan. The Strategic Business Plan will be based on the strategic, operational, and
financial elements produced throughout the project.
=> Deliverable: Strategic Business Plan draft created.
City Role: Participate in writing certain sections of the plan. There are some sections that
may require deeper City input and where hands-on experience is important for building staff
capacity to create new plans in the future.
Task C. Forecast Update. The information provided through the foregoing phase will enable
the City and GFOA to refine the forecast further. More in-depth information on the resource
requirements needed to put the Strategic Business Plan into operation will enable the City to
create more detailed spending scenarios. It is anticipated that the City will lead this forecast
update, but GFOA will advise how to best incorporate these scenarios into the Municast model.
=> Deliverable: Advise City on how to incorporate new information into Municast.
=> City Role: Update Municast model and make forecast.
Task D. Final Plan. After the draft plan is delivered, there will be a review and comment period
after which will be a public meeting to present the plan. GFOA will help the City design the
meeting and will participate in the meeting.
=> Deliverable: Public meeting held to present plan after the plan has received thorough review
and approval by appropriate City participants.
City Role: Coordinate meeting, help present plan.
Phase 7 - Linking to the Budget Process
Task A. Designing Link between Business Plan and Budget. The budget process is one of the
most important methods for executing the Strategic Business Plan. GFOA will work with City
staff on a process for assuring that the plan becomes the basis for the budget — or, at minimum, is
a critical input to the budgeting process.
z* Deliverable: GFOA works with City on a per -hour basis to advise on linkages, develop
forms, etc.
=> City Role: Respond to GFOA suggestions on how to use hours and otherwise approve how
hours will be used.
Phase 8 — Documentation and Wrap -Up
Task A. Project Review. Taking the time to reflect on the project and identify what aspects of
the project the City wants to save, delete, and change going forward is the first step towards
developing an on-going Strategic Business Planning cycle.
=> Deliverable: Review project with Strategic Plan Steering Committee.
=> City Role: Participate in meeting.
Task B. Develop On-going Strategic Business Plan Process. GFOA will propose a final on -
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
34
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
going Strategic Business Planning model for the City that can be maintained independent of
consultant support. The final recommended process will make use of the tools and techniques
used during this project, as well as lessons for how these tools and techniques can be better
adapted to the City's on-going use.
=> Deliverables: A process map to depict the final recommended process, including the links
into the budget process.
=> City Roles: Review and provide feedback on final process
Task C. Transitioning the Strategic Plan Steering Committee to Implementation. GFOA
will help the City transition the Committee's role to implementation. We will help the City
define the Committee's responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources for the
implementation of the plan.
=> Deliverables: A charter for the Steering Committee's implementation role.
=> City Roles: Participate in meeting to develop charter.
D. Out -of -Scope Activities
We believe that our proposal provides a comprehensive response to the City's RFP, however,
there are some activities that are not within the scope of proposal that the City should be aware
of.
• Community Surveys. GFOA does not conduct community surveys. GFOA recommends
that the City contract with a specialized survey firm for that service.
• Land -Use Planning. While GFOA understands that land -use planning is not in the scope of
the RFP, we understand that land -use is an important consideration for San Juan Capistrano.
GFOA is not a land -use planning firm. If expert input is needed on land -use GFOA
recommends that the City contract separately with the firm that normally supports its land -
use master planning or that internal land use planning staff provide expert knowledge. In our
experience, internal staff can fill this role by being integrated into the strategic business
planning team structure.
Section 3 - Timetable/Schedule of Required Tasks
Section 2 describes all key project tasks, deliverables for each phase, and the GFOA and City's
roles in each. The Gantt chart below describes the timeline for this project. Completing the
project in October of 2008 will allow the City to use the Strategic Business Plan as a lead-in to
its budget process. This should provide plenty of lead time for any more extensive budget
procedures that the City and GFOA deem necessary.
March April May June July Aug Sept Oct
A. Designate Leader
B. Establish Teams
C. Involvement Strategy
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
35
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
A. Stakeholder Input
B. Mission & Vision
A. Financial Analysis
A. Templates Developed
B. Plan & Measures Developed
C. Forecast Update
On -Going Planning Process
Transition to Implementation
Section 4 - Identify the Team
This section includes: A) The proposing firms; B) Contact information; C) Location of the work;
D) Organization chart; and E)Proposed team members.
A. The Proposing Firm
The GFOA is the primary proposing firm. The GFOA was established in 1906. It is the premier
professional association for government finance professionals in the United States and Canada
and has more than 17,500 members. As a non-profit educational organization, GFOA's mission
is to enhance and promote the professional management of governments for the public's benefit.
GFOA identifies and develops best practices in the area of long-range and strategic planning and
budgeting and promotes them through a national training program, books and other publications,
and an annual conference.
The Research and Consulting Center is GFOA's research and analysis and management
consulting division. The GFOA is nationally recognized for its comprehensive analytical and
advisory services, as well as for its practitioner -oriented research on issues related to state and
local government finance. GFOA staff work closely with practitioners to develop and
disseminate recommended practices in all of the functional areas of public finance. In addition,
the GFOA publishes books and periodicals, and coordinates GFOA's national training program
and annual conference.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
36
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Since beginning operations in 1977, the Research and Consulting Center has undertaken
hundreds of projects with state and local governments, federal agencies, and private sector
clients. The GFOA provides financial and management consulting services in the areas of
strategic plartning, long-term financial planning, performance measurement, debt capacity
analysis, multi-year budgeting, and operational reviews, among others.
GFOA is partnering with the Government Finance Research Group to provide the
Municast financial forecasting software model. The Municast solution is 100% based on
Microsoft Excel and will not require the City to purchase any new software from GFOA or the
Government Finance Research Group. Municast is currently in use by over 20 California
municipalities.
B. Contact Information
The primary contact for this proposal is Anne Spray Kinney, the Director of the GFOA Research
and Consulting Center (RCC). Anne can be reached at 312-917-6102 or at akinneyAgfoa.org.
The secondary contact for this project is Shayne Kavanagh, Senior Manager of Research for the
GFOA RCC. He can be reached at 312-578-2276 or at skavanagh afoe a.org.
C. Location of the Work
GFOA proposes a combination of on-site work at the City's premises and off-site work at GFOA
and Municast offices. GFOA offices are located in Chicago. Government Finance Research
Group offices are located in San Juan Capistrano.
D. Organization Chart
GFOA proposes that the City's Strategic Plan Steering Committee play an overall governance
role, while the project leader acts as the official engagement manager. GFOA also proposes that
the City set up a parallel team structure to GFOA's team, including a project coordinator who
will handle many of the day-to-day activities of the project. The City's team would be supervised
by the City's coordinator but both the coordinator and the City's teams would have a great deal
of interaction with GFOA's team as they work together on the planning process. We believe this
structure will provide valuable hands-on experience for the City. Please note that the final
structure and names of the City's teams would be determined jointly with the City.
gic Plan Stegng o= mittee
.
Strategic & I Financial Plan
1 I GFOA Financial
GFOA Strategic & Analysts
Business Plan
Analysts
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
37
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
E. Proposed Team Members
GFOA assigns a small group of highly qualified individuals to consulting projects it undertakes.
Nearly all of GFOA's consultants have worked as managers in local government or hold
advanced degrees in public policy or administration. All of our project managers have worked as
government managers. GFOA's staff of professionals is directly involved in GFOA's continuing
professional education programs (some as instructors), including national training seminars and
the annual conference. Government finance is our business, and our consultants are eminently
qualified to perform the type of work the City is requesting. Below are our proposed staff
members. Complete bios for our team are available in "Section 5 - Qualifications and Related
Experience."
Project Role
Team Member Name
Project Manager
Anne Spray Kinney
Strategic & Business Plan Manager
Steve Kreklow
Financial Planning Manager
Sha ne Kavanagh
Facilitation Assistance
David Burna
Lead Strategic/Business Plan Analyst
John Ruggini
Strate icBusiness Plan Analyst
Christine Lambino
Strate is/Business Plan Analyst
Mike Mucha
Financial Plan Analyst
Brenda Boyle
Municast Configuration
Chris Swanson
Anne Kinney and Shayne Kavanagh are the team principles. Their contact information was
provided earlier in this section.
Section 5 - Qualifications and Related Experience
This section includes: A) GFOA's strategic and financial planning expertise; B) Recent directly
related experience; C) Key personnel who will be involved in the project; D) Other public
entities to which we have provided services.
A. GFOA's Strategic and Financial Planning Expertise
GFOA's team for this project has long-term experience developing governmental strategic plans
and financial plans. Anne Spray Kinney and Stephen Kreklow, senior team members on this
project, have worked both as government practitioners and consultants with state, regional, and
local governments to create integrated strategic planning -performance measurement -budgeting
systems and also have developed strategic plans and implementation plans for sub -organizational
systems, such as performance measurement and management systems and large organizational
re -designs.
GFOA's experience and resources in performance measurement and management are
equally strong, based on the experience of team members, GFOA's research, and its ability to
call on its membership base for examples of high quality processes and documents.
GFOA's expertise in financial planning for local government is unsurpassed. We have
been providing consulting on long-term financial planning since 2001 and we have published the
leading book on the topic, Financing the Future: Long -Term Financial Planning for Local
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 38
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Government. Shayne Kavanagh, the author of this book, is a senior member of our proposed
project team. We have been invited to speak on financial planning at the annual conferences for
the International City/County Management Association, that National League of Cities, as well
as a number of state -level organizations including the California Society of Municipal Finance
Officers. We have also published articles on financial planning in leading journals such as
Government Finance Review, Public Management, and School Business Affairs.
GFOA is constantly honing our expertise on this topic as well. We maintain a Web site
dedicated to financial planning at www. fog a.org/Itfp, which is regularly updated with new
resources. We are currently working with the National League of Cities to conduct research
designed to deepen our understanding of how elected officials can participate in financial
planning and plan to publish a new book on the subject in the early summer of 2008.
B. Recent Directly Related Experience
Below are our recent directly related experiences. Those experiences that we believe will be of
most interest to the City are presented first.
Milwaukee (Wisconsin) Public Schools
• Description of Work: Performance Measurement and Budgeting, including identification of
strategic objectives and long-range strategies (derived from previous MPS planning
processes), performance measures, annual targets, and a performance-based budget within
in a linked system. GFOA worked with the school district administration to identify district -
wide long-term outcomes and strategies derived from previous planning efforts to guide
development of performance measures and an annual performance budget, and then assisted
the District to develop a performance-based budget. GFOA also provided training, meeting
facilitation, and coaching to departmental managers, as well as a performance measurement
and budgeting handbook.
• Primary Client Contact: Michelle Nate, CFO, Milwaukee Public Schools, (414) 475-
8336, natemi(.&mail.milwaukee.kl2.wi.us.
• Dates for Project: October 2006 to present.
• Project Manager: Stephen Kreklow
• Members of Team on Project: Anne Kinney, Steve Kreklow, Mike Mucha, Christine
Lambino
• Project Costs: $150,280
City of Gresham, Oregon
• Description of Work: Long-term financial planning advisory services, including a debt
affordability analysis and peer group analysis.
• Primary Client Contact:
o Terry McCall, Finance and Management Services Director, (503) 618-2372,
Terry.MCCall(a.Cl.gresham.or.us, 1333 NW Eastman Pkwy, Gresham, OR 97030
o Deborah Bond, Acting Finance Director, (503) 618-2855,
Deborah. Bondnci.gresham.or.us, 1333 NW Eastman Pkwy, Gresham, OR 97030
• Dates for Project: GFOA first worked with Gresham in 2001. In this project, GFOA took
the lead role in developing the plan. Gresham in late 2006 sought to refresh the plan but this
time GFOA took a more hands-off advisory role, while Gresham did most of the work. With
GFOA's guidance they completed a new plan in 2007.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 39
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
• Name of Project Manager: Shayne Kavanagh (both in 2001 and 2007)
• Members of Team on Project: Shayne Kavanagh, project manager, Steve Kreklow, Lead
Analyst, Anne Kinney, Engagement Manager
• Project Costs: 2001 - $47,500; 2006/07 - $25,000
City of Montclair, California
• Description of Work: Long-term financial planning advisory services, including
development of multi-year strategic business plan.
• Primary Client Contact: Edward Starr, Director of Administrative Services, (909) 625-
9405, ecstarr a ci.montclair.ca.us, 5111 Benito Street, Montclair, CA 91763
• Dates for Project: GFOA first worked with Montclair in 2001. The City was very pleased
with strategic planning and has asked GFOA back every summer since, with our most recent
engagement completing in 2007.
• Name of Project Manager: Shayne Kavanagh (starting in 2001 and each year since)
• Members of Team on Project: Shayne Kavanagh, Anne Kinney, Engagement Manager
• Project Costs: 2001 - $35,000; average cost for annual engagements $10,000.
City of San Clemente, California
• Description of Work: Assist the City with refining its financial planning process to better
engage elected officials in the process.
• Primary Client Contact: Pall Gudgeirsson, Treasurer/Assistant City Manager, (949) 361-
8341, GudgeirssonPksan-Clemente.org, 100 Avenida Presidio, San Clemente, CA 92672
• Dates for Project: GFOA commenced and completed this project in late 2007.
• Name of Project Manager: Shayne Kavanagh
• Members of Team on Project: Shayne Kavanagh, project manager, lead analyst
• Project Costs: $2,000
C. Key Personnel
Below are the key personnel on the GFOA team and their biographies.
Anne Spray Kinney is Director of the Research and Consulting Center of the Government
Finance Officers Association. Ms. Kinney has more than 20 years' experience in local
government, much of it as a practitioner. Before becoming a consultant, Ms.. Kinney served as
budget director and subsequently administration director for the City of Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
and was the executive director of Milwaukee's regional flood control -water reclamation
authority in addition to other management positions in state and local government. Before
coming to GFOA, Ms. Kinney was a Senior Partner at the Public Strategies Group. Ms. Kinney
has managed a broad array of organizational improvement efforts, and has conducted numerous
strategic planning -budgeting -performance measurement processes and organizational
assessments at the city, county and state government level. Ms. Kinney has designed and
implemented integrated planning -performance measurement budgeting systems, information
technology strategy, customer service and compliance plans; procurement and contracting plans
and systems, and government -wide managed competition programs. Ms. Kinney has also
conducted projects focused on human resource services, revenue enhancement, business process
improvement, and intergovernmental service sharing. In addition to consulting, Ms. Kinney is a
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 40
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
frequent presenter on these topics to national audiences and has published articles on strategic
planning, results budgeting, performance management, privatization and outsourcing, and
leadership in the public sector and has taught government financial management at the graduate
level. Ms. Kinney holds a BA from American University and an MPA from the University of
Illinois -Chicago.
Steven R. Kreklow has more than 15 years experience as a manager in local government.
Before joining GFOA he was the Budget Director and Human Resources Manager for
Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District and previously served as Finance & Planning
Manager for the city of Milwaukee's Department of Public Works. In addition he has served as
an operations manager for municipal services as diverse as parking and forestry. While at the
Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District, Steve was responsible for strategic and long-term
financial planning and development of the operating budget and capital improvements program
as well as directing internal analysis on the financing of the District's 2020 Facilities
Improvement Plan. GFOA's Distinguished Budget Presentation Award Program recognized two
of the budget documents prepared under Mr. Kreklow's direction for "Outstanding Use of
Performance Measures." His clients include Genesee County, Michigan and the City of
Milwaukee Department of Public Works where he was the project manager for a strategic
planning process. He was also project manager for performance measurement system
development projects at Sacramento County, California, and Milwaukee Public Schools and was
a key project team member on long-term financial planning projects in Gresham, Oregon, and
Rialto, California. Mr. Kreklow consults, researches, and trains in the areas of strategic planning,
budgeting, financial management, performance measurement, technology, and organizational
development. He also regularly teaches government finance courses for universities and
continuing education programs in the Milwaukee area. Mr. Kreklow holds a Master of Public
Administration from the University of Wisconsin -Milwaukee.
Shayne Kavanagh is the Senior Manager of Research for GFOA. Mr. Kavanagh has worked on
a number of strategic planning and long-term planning projects. He served as the project
manager for projects at the City of Montclair, California, the City of Gresham, Oregon, the City
of Rialto, California, and the City of San Clemente, California. Mr. Kavanagh has authored the
GFOA publications Financing the Future: Long -Term Financial Planning for Local Government
and Financial Policies: Design and Implementation. He has spoken on the topic of financial
planning and policies at the California Society of Municipal Finance Officers, the New England
States GFOA, the Michigan Government Finance Officers Association, the International
City/County Management Association, National League of Cities, and GFOA annual conference.
He has written articles on financial planning that have appeared in journals such as Government
Finance Review, Puhlic Management, and School Business Affairs. Prior to joining GFOA, Mr.
Kavanagh was the Assistant Village Manager for the Village of Palos Park, Illinois. Mr.
Kavanagh graduated from with his MPA degree from Northern Illinois University where he was
the ASPA student of the year for his graduating class.
David Burna is a Senior Manager in the GFOA Research and Consulting Center. Mr. Burna
specializes in the development and implementation of strategic planning and change
management projects. Mr. Burna specializes in facilitation, business process re-engineering, and
decision analysis for government. Mr. Burna has conducted business process mapping,
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 41
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
evaluation, and re-engineering efforts for the numerous clients. Recent projects include: City of
Overland Park (KS); City of Newport News (VA); City of Topeka (KS); City of Raleigh (NC);
and County of Marin (CA). Mr. Burna has an MPP in Environmental Policy from Harvard
University's John F. Kennedy School of Government. Mr. Burrta has worked with both private
firms and public agencies on a wide variety of strategic planning projects. He has helped clients
to manage stakeholder involvement, public relations, investment strategies, and mergers &
acquisitions. Mr. Burna has developed training courses for technical and public sector
professionals looking to enhance both their facilitation and long-range planning skills. He has
implemented long-range planning solutions for institutions as diverse as the South Florida Water
Management District (SFWMD), Department of Energy (DoE), Chevron Pipeline, City of New
York - Parks & Recreation Department, Los Angeles Department of Public Works - Bureau of
Sanitation, and the New York City Department of Environmental Protection.
John Ruggini is a Manager with the GFOA and works extensively in the area of performance
measurement. He manages the research for the State and Local Government Performance
Measurement Sourcebook (to be published in spring 2008). He has conducted research on
budget and performance measurement systems for San Luis Obispo County and provided
consulting assistance to the City and County of San Francisco for a budget and performance
measurement system. Mr. Ruggini also led the development of GFOA's toolkit to help local
governments understand and manage their "other post -employment benefit" (OPEB) liabilities.
Before joining GFOA, he worked in the City Administrator's office at the City of St. Charles,
Illinois where he served as the primary coordinator for the performance measurement program in
conjunction with the International City/County Managers Association's (ICMA) Center for
Performance Measurement. He also conducted annual assessments of financial trends, which
included benchmarked ratio analysis of the City's financial condition and assisted with the
development of departmental business plans. Mr. Ruggini received his MPA from Northern
Illinois University.
Mike Mucha is a Consultant/Analyst with the GFOA and focuses on management and
technology research and consulting. He researches local governments' use of performance
measures and coordinates all GFOA training sessions on performance measurement and
budgeting. Mr. Mucha has worked with the Milwaukee Public School District to implement
performance-based budgeting and was involved with creating a performance measurement
guidebook for Sacramento County. Mr. Mucha co -edited GFOA's recent publication: Capital
Project Planning and Evaluation. Prior to coming to GFOA, Mr. Mucha worked with the Sports
& Exhibition Authority of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County. He received a Master of Science in
Public Policy and Management from the Heinz School of Public Policy and Management at
Carnegie Mellon University.
Brenda Boyle is a Consultant/Policy Analyst in the GFOA. Ms. Boyle is heavily involved in
GFOA's long-term financial planning program. She has developed GFOA's training course on
financial planning, conducted case -study research, and provided consulting services. She has
also conducted extensive research on use of performance measurement and strategic planning at
the state level for GFOA's upcoming Performance Measurement Sourcebook publication. She
has also participated in a performance-based budgeting consulting project for Genesee County,
Michigan. Ms. Boyle received an MPA with concentration in Public Financial Administration
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 42
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
from Indiana University's School of Public & Environmental Affairs.
Christine Lambino is a Consultant/Analyst with the GFOA. Ms. Lambino has worked with
Milwaukee Public School District and Genesee County, Michigan, to implement performance-
based budgeting. Ms. Lambino also assists with research related to government use of
performance measures and budgeting for outcomes. Prior to working at GFOA, Ms. Lambino
held positions in local governments including King County, Washington, and the Village of
Wilmette, Illinois. Ms. Lambino holds an MPA from Northwestern University.
Christopher J. Swanson is the founder of Government Finance Research Group (GFRG), a
financial management consulting firm specializing in financial planning, research, cost analysis,
econometric modeling, benchmarking and optimization modeling for local governments throughout
the U.S. Chris developed an innovative financial forecasting and analysis model called, MuniCast&
Municast is in use by over 20 cities across California. Chris' background includes 20 years of
government and corporate financial management, including senior financial and strategic planning
roles at the City of Los Angeles, United Healthcare Systems, HealthNet and The Walt Disney
Company. Chris has developed complex economic and financial models, implemented performance
measurement systems and led process improvement initiatives at public and private sector
organizations. His academic credentials include an MBA from UCLA's Anderson Graduate School
of Management and BA in Political Science from California State University, Northridge. GFRG is a
sole proprietorship based in California.
D. Other Public Entities Served
GFOA has provided consulting services to over 100 public entities. Section 5-13 describes those
of greatest relevance to this project.
Section 6 - Other Information
A. Optional Services
This section describes services that could enhance the City's planning process, but that GFOA
does not believe are essential based on the City's RFP.
Additional Focus Group/Interview Support. GFOA can conduct additional focus groups /
interviews over what our proposal assumes.
Additional Support in Other Areas. Our approach places progressively greater responsibility
on the City staff for to improve the City's ability to plan after the GFOA's engagement is
completed. GFOA is happy to provide deeper support and take a more hands-on role if the City
prefers.
Municast Customization. Additional features can be added to Municast on a per -hour
consultative basis. The City will receive the new "all funds" version of Municast which includes
a great number of new features. As such, it is unlikely that the City will need to perform
additional customization.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 43
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
B. About Our Discount
GFOA conducts consulting engagements as part of our mission of identifying, helping to
develop, and broadly disseminating best practices in governmental management. Because of the
comprehensive nature of this project we believe that the results are likely to contribute to "best
practices" that can be shared with other governments. GFOA is therefore pleased to be able to
provide a 15% discount on our fees.
C. Key Assumptions
• City staff provides data and participates in interview and other activities requested by GFOA.
• A single point of contact from the City is identified;
• GFOA undertakes no more than the indicated number of on-site trips within the price
included in this proposal.
o Trip #I - Interview stakeholders on defining success and perception of environment,
meeting with Strategic Plan Steering Committee, conduct technical planning
workshops (forecasting, environmental modeling, etc.). 3 days, 2 people
o Trip #2 — Conduct focus groups, 2 days, 2 people
o Trip #3 — Conduct mission workshop, 1 day, 2 people
o Trip #4 — Strategic issues retreat, 2 days, 2 people
o Trip #5 — Business plan workshop 2 days, 2 people
o Trip #6 — Present draft plan to committee 1 day, 2 people
o Trip #7 — Present draft plan to public 1 day, 2 people
• GFOA's role in the development of a plan is consultative and advisory in nature. The City
will play an important role in data collection, participating as partners in plan development,
and will make any final decisions on strategy and direction.
• The project scope is not expanded beyond the items listed in the proposal at the proposed
(discounted) price, unless so negotiated with the GFOA.
• As an educational, nonprofit, professional membership association, GFOA reserves the right
to publish non -confidential documents describing the results of, or created during, the
services described in this scope of work. GFOA will not publish any item with the name of
the City of San Juan Capistrano without obtaining prior written consent of the government.
• GFOA develops its reports to be clear and concise. We focus on brevity in order to make our
reports accessible to the public and elected officials.
• GFOA is a non-profit membership association made up of members like the City of San Juan
Capistrano and therefore we have no owners' equity to fall back on. Therefore, GFOA's
liability and indemnification under any agreement reached with the City must be limited to
the extent of fees paid by GFOA's insurance coverage. (Please note that this limitation would
require an amendment to the City's standard Personal Services Agreement.)
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 44
EXHIBIT "C"
Revised Contract Fee
The fee would be payable in stages as shown below. We estimate travel expenses based on 9
trips as shown in "Exhibit A - Statement of Work - Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business
Planning City of San Juan Capistrano."
GFOA's standard rates range from $250/hour for Senior Staff to $175 for Consultant Analysts.
Phase„
=k
�
P
#
„Rroject, a
Pa"men
°
Phase
Start-up activities and Phase 1 deliverables
1
provided to City
10,030
Fixed
Phase
Phase 2 deliverables provided to City
2
(except focusgroup)
13,090
Fixed
Phase
2
Focus group deliverable completed
12,500
Fixed
Phase
3
Phase 3 deliverables provided to City
10,030
Fixed
Phase
4
Phase 4 deliverables provided to City
8,075
Fixed
Phase
4
1 Focus group deliverable completed
12,500
Fixed
Phase
Business planning templates and workshop
5
completed
8,075
Fixed
Phase
5
Business plan consultation completed
1,870
Fixed
Phase
6
Strategic Business Plan presented
4,250
Fixed
Phase
7
Budget linkage designed
4,250
1 Fixed
Phase
8
Phase 8 deliverables provided to City
3,060
Fixed
Travel
Travel Estimate
15,000
Not -to -Exceed
TOTAL
102,730
GFOA's standard rates range from $250/hour for Senior Staff to $175 for Consultant Analysts.
32400 PASEO ADEI—ANTO
SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO, CA 92675
(949) 4931171
(949) 49310531"
www. sanjuancaptstrano. org
TRANSMITTAL
TO:
Anne Spray Kinney
Government Finance Officers Association
203 N. LaSalle, Suite 2700
Chicago, Illinois 60601
MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
SAM ALLEVATO
THOMAS W. HRIBAR
MARK NIELSEN
JOE SOTO
DR. LONDRES USO
DATE: July 2, 2008
FROM: Maria Morris, Deputy City Clerk (949) 443-6309
RE: Personal Services Agreement — Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning
Thank you for providing documentation confirming compliance with the terms of the agreement
related to insurance.
Please keep in mind this documentation must remain current with our office during the term of
this agreement. If you have questions related to insurance requirements, please contact
me at (949) 443-6309.
If you have questions concerning the agreement, please contact Cindy L. Russell, Assistant
City Manager at (949) 443-6301.
An original agreement is enclosed for your records.
Cc: Cindy L. Russell, Assistant City Manager
San Juan Capistrano: Preserving the Past to Enhance the Future
0 Printed on 100% recyGetl paper
6/17/2008
AGENDA REPORT D14
TO: Dave Adams, City Manager
FROM: Cindy Russell, Assistant City Manager
SUBJECT: Consideration of Agreement for Long -Term Vision/Strategic Business
Planning Services (GFOA) (City Council Priority No. 21B)
RECOMMENDATION:
By motion, approve the agreement with the Government Finance Officers Association
(GFOA) to provide services relating to the development of the City's Long -Term Vision
and Strategic Business Plan in the amount of $102,300.
SITUATION:
Summary and Recommendation:
The City Council has identified and prioritized the need to develop a long-term vision
and strategic business plan for the City. The City is beginning to transition from a
growing city to a more mature, "built -out" community and will soon not be able to count
on new revenue from growth to the extent it did in the past. The purpose of this plan is
to align the community's values and decisions about "who we are" and what our
community represents with the desire to continue our strong level of service to the
community, maintain our infrastructure, and maintain a solid financial position for the
future, Therefore, the City Council has identified the need to develop a long-term vision
and strategic plan that is supported by a solid long-term financial analysis, detailed
implementation strategies, and performance measures.
The plan would identify:
• Strategies - Broad goals and values the City sees for the future and desires to
accomplish and maintain.
• Tactics - The City's projects, methods, and movements toward the successful
outcome of the City's strategies. For example, if the strategy is to "Support
Economic Development", a tactic could be developing a competitive hotel market
or encourage business ventures that will help to diversify our sales tax base.
Agenda Report
Page 2 June 17, 2008
• Goals - The measuring tool for each tactic. For example, if the tactic is
developing a competitive hotel market, the measurable goal would be to have an
increase of XX% in hotel revenues each year or to increase sales tax from a
certain business type.
The long-term vision would be consensus based and involve the efforts of the
community, City Council, and City staff. The strategic business plan would be the
framework around which all the City's programs, projects, activities, and financial
resources would be structured and allocated. In an effort to provide professional and
technical expertise in this area and facilitate this process, the City has identified the
need to retain a consulting firm with experience in this area.
Staff recommends the City Council approve the agreement with the Government
Finance Officers Association (GFOA) to provide services relating to the development of
the City's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan in the amount of $102,300.
Background:
City staff prepared a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) and submitted this to
approximately a dozen firms. The City received two proposals with costs as follows:
GFOA $77,300
PFM Group (Long-term financial plan only) $75,000
The City has formed a project committee which includes City staff and two City Council
members appointed by the Mayor. The Mayor has appointed Mayor -Pro Tem Mark
Nielsen and Council member Sam Allevato to serve on this committee. The initial
project committee reviewed both proposals and interviewed both firms. Based on the
results of this process, the project committee's recommendation is to retain GFOA to
provide services in support of the development of the City's long-term vision and
strategic business plan.
GFOA is a non-profit association of US and Canadian governments with more than
17,000 members and 100 years of experience in the area of governmental finance. The
purpose of GFOA is to enhance and promote the professional management of
governments for the public benefit by identifying and developing financial policies and
practices and promoting them through education, training, and leadership. GFOA
provides for government consulting only with a strong background in strategic planning
and long-term financial planning. The GFOA project team includes government
management and finance professionals with more than 20 years of experience each.
Some of their California clients include the cities of San Clemente, Montclair, and
Stockton. GFOA will also be developing and implementing with the City staff the
MuniCast product, an excel -based revenue, expenditure trend, and sensitivity analysis
model.
Agenda Report
Page 3 June 17, 2008
The main objectives of the process as proposed by GFOA and outlined in the attached
agreement are as follows:
Objective 1: The City has articulated a clear and concise mission and vision for the
community that is consensus -based. (A mission and vision statement will be developed
early in the project so that it can be used as a yardstick and reference point for the
remainder of the project.)
Objective 2: The City has created a written Strategic Business Plan that articulates
critical strategic and fiscal issues, includes objectives and strategies for addressing
these issues, and links these to programs, services, and activities related to daily
operations and consequently to the budget process via performance measures that will
be used to gauge progress. (The plan will be based on a comprehensive environmental
analysis that includes a thorough financial situational analysis.)
Objective 3: The City's Strategic Business Plan contains a long-term financial
perspective (5, 10 and 20 -year forecasts) and provides strategies for maintaining fiscal
stability. (The plan includes an assessment of the city's financial structure, projects
revenues and expenditures over the long term, identifies potential structural and cyclical
imbalances, and proposes courses of action for addressing them.)
Objective 4: The City has the appropriate knowledge base, tools, and processes for
regularly reviewing its financial situation, including a financial trend monitoring system
and a computerized financial modeling and forecasting system. (GFOA's approach
provides templates and tools that can be adopted by the City and focuses on working
with City staff throughout the project to provide staff with hands-on experience.)
Objective 5: The City has a performance measurement and management system that
supports the implementation of the strategic, operational, and financial goals and that
provides key indicators of progress so that elected officials, the public, and city
managers will be able to track progress and know how the City is performing.
Objective 6: The project is conducted using an approach that
• Is inclusive and is perceived as such so that the resulting plan has broad community
support.
• Involves city staff as partners with consultants so that the planning cycle and system
can be sustained independent of external advisory or consulting support in the
future.
Lastly, in an effort to assure as much community involvement as possible, the project
committee requested expanded work in the area of community involvement and focus
groups. GFOA provided and expanded scope of work increasing the number of focus
groups from four to twelve and providing increased community involvement at a cost of
$25,000. This would bring the total cost to $102,300.
Agenda Report
Page 4 June 17, 2008
COMMISSION/BOARD REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
N/A
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
The FY 2007/08 budget includes funding for this City Council priority and these funds
will be carried forward to FY 2008/09 to implement this process.
NOTIFICATION:
Shayne Kavanaugh, GFOA*
* Agenda Report included
RECOMMENDATION:
By motion, approve the agreement with the Government Finance Officers Association
(GFOA) to provide services relating to the development of the City's Long -Term Vision
and Strategic Business Plan in the amount of $102,300.
Respectfully submitted,
CRell
Assistant City Manager
Attachment:
1. GFOA Agreement
GFOA AGREEMENT BEING FINALIZED AND WILL BE SUBMITTED UNDER A
SUPPLEMENTAL AGENDA ITEM PRIOR TO THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
ATTACHMENT
32400 PASEO ADEL.ANTO
SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO, CA 92675
(949) 493-1171
(949) 493.1053 FAX
www.sanjuancapistrano.org
MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
NOTIFICATION OF MEETING OF POTENTIAL INTEREST
OF THE SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO CITY COUNCIL
SAM ALLEVATO
THOMAS W. HRIBAR
MARK NIELSEN
JOE SOTO
DR. LONDRES USO
The City Council of San Juan Capistrano will meet at 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, June 17,
2008 in the City Council Chamber in City Hall, to consider: "Consideration of
Agreement for Long -Term Vision/Strategic Business Planning Services (GFOA)
(City Council Priority No. 21B)" — Item No. D14.
If you have specific thoughts or concerns regarding this item, you are encouraged to
participate in this decision making process. You can communicate with the City Council
through correspondence addressed to the Council and/or by attending the meeting and
speaking to the Council during the public meeting.
Correspondence related to this item must be received at the City Clerk's office by 5:00
p.m. on Monday, June 16, 2008 to allow time for the Council to consider its content.
If you would like to speak at the meeting, please complete a yellow "Request to Speak"
form found inside the entrance to the Council Chamber. This form is turned in at the
staff table, just in front of the Council dais. You will be called to speak by the Mayor
when the item is considered.
You have received this notice at the request of the City staff member Cindy Russell,
Assistant City Manager. You may contact that staff member at (949) 443-6302 with any
questions.
The agenda, including agenda reports, is available to you on our web site:
www.san*uancapistrano.org. If you would like to subscribe to receive a notice when
agendas are posted to the web site, please make that request by sending an e-mail to:
cityclerk(a)sanivancapistrano.org.
Meg Monahan, MMC
City Clerk
cc: Shayne Kavanaugh, GFOA*; Cindy Russell, Assistant City Manager
" Received staff report
San Juan Capistrano: Preserving the Past to Enhance the Future
40 Printed on 100% recycled paper
6/17/2008
SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA REPORT D14
TO: Dave Adams, City Manager V r
FROM: Cindy Russell, Assistant City Manager
SUBJECT: Consideration of Agreement for Long -Term Vision/Strategic Business
Planning Services (GFOA) (City Council Priority No. 21B)
RECOMMENDATION
By motion, approve the agreement with the Government Finance Officers Association
(GFOA) to provide services relating to the development of the City's Long -Term Vision
and Strategic Business Plan in the amount of $102,730, and authorize the City Manager
to execute the agreement.
SITUATION:
Staff has been working the City's project committee and GFOA to refine and finalize the
workplan component of the proposed agreement. The attached proposed agreement
with GFOA for long-term vision/strategic business planning services has been
completed and being presented for City Council consideration.
NOTIFICATION:
Shayne Kavanaugh, GFOA*
RECOMMENDATION:
By motion, approve the agreement with the Government Finance Officers Association
(GFOA) to provide services relating to the development of the City's Long -Term Vision
and Strategic Business Plan in the amount of $102,730 and authorize the City Manager
to execute the agreement.
nRespecttullymitteW
11
Cindy Russell
Assistant City Manager
Attachment:
1. GFOA Agreement
PERSONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT is made, entered into, and shall become effective this 11th
day of June, 2008, by and between the City of San Juan Capistrano (hereinafter
referred to as the "City") and Government Finance Officers Association (hereinafter
referred to as the "Consultant").
RECITALS:
WHEREAS, City desires to retain the services of Consultant regarding the City's
proposal for Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning and
WHEREAS, Consultant is qualified by virtue of experience, training, education
and expertise to accomplish such services.
NOW, THEREFORE, City and Consultant mutually agree as follows:
Section 1. Scope of Work.
The scope of work to be performed by the City shall consist of those tasks as set
forth in Exhibit "A - Statement of Work - Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business
Planning City of San Juan Capistrano," and Exhibit "B - GFOA Long -Term Vision and
Strategic Business Plan Proposal for The City of San Juan Capistrano", attached and
incorporated herein by reference; the provisions in Exhibit "A" shall control any conflicts
between provisions in Exhibit "A" and Exhibit "B." To the extent that there are any
conflicts between the provisions described in Exhibit "A" and those provisions contained
within this Agreement, the provisions in this Agreement shall control.
Section 2. Term.
This Agreement shall commence on the effective date and shall terminate when
all services required hereunder shall be completed, no later than May 2009.
Section 3. Compensation.
3.1 Amount
Total compensation for the services hereunder shall not exceed $102,730
as set forth in Exhibit "C" attached and incorporated herein by reference.
3.2 Method of Payment.
Subject to Section 3.1, Consultant shall submit invoices based upon each
phase of work that has been satisfactorily completed. The amount of each phase
invoice shall be as outlined in Exhibit "C". Invoices shall be paid within 30 days of the
ATTACHMENT
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
City's approval of the deliverables for the related phase of work. A deliverable will be
deemed "satisfactorily completed," and GFOA will invoice the City 1) upon notification of
satisfaction by the City's designed representative; or 2) 30 -days subsequent to the date
GFOA provided the City with the deliverable, whichever comes first. The City may
request one set of revisions to a deliverable within 30 days from the date GFOA sends
the first version of the deliverable. If revisions are requested, the date the .phase has
been satisfactorily completed will occur 30days following the date GFOA sends the
revised deliverable to the City.
3.3 Records of Expenses.
Consultant shall keep complete and accurate records of all costs and
expenses incidental to services covered by this Agreement. These records will be
made available at reasonable times to City.
Section 4. Independent Contractor.
It is agreed that Consultant shall act and be an independent contractor and not
an agent or employee of City, and shall obtain no rights to any benefits which accrue to
City's employees.
Section 5. Limitations Upon Subcontractina and Assignment.
The experience, knowledge, capability and reputation of Consultant, its principals
and employees were a substantial inducement for City to enter into this Agreement.
Consultant shall not contract with any other entity to perform the services required
without written approval of the City. This Agreement may not be assigned, voluntarily or
by operation of law, without the prior written approval of the City. If Consultant is
permitted to subcontract any part of this Agreement by City, Consultant shall be
responsible to City for the acts and omissions of its subcontractor as it is for persons
directly employed. Nothing contained in this Agreement shall create any contractual
relationships between any subcontractor and City. All persons engaged in the work will
be considered employees of Consultant. City will deal directly with and will make all
payments to Consultant.
Section 6. Chances to Scope of Work.
For extra work not part of this Agreement, a written authorization from City is
required prior to Consultant undertaking any extra work. In the event of a change in the
Scope of Work provided for in the contract documents as requested by the City, the
Parties hereto shall execute an addendum to this Agreement setting forth with
particularity all terms of the new agreement, including but not limited to any additional
Consultant's fees.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 7. Familiarity with Work and/or Construction Site.
By executing this Agreement, Consultant warrants that: (1) it has investigated
the work to be performed; (2) if applicable, it has investigated the work site(s), and is
aware of all conditions there; and (3) it understands the facilities, difficulties and
restrictions of the work to be performed under this Agreement. Should Consultant
discover any latent or unknown conditions materially differing from those inherent in the
work or as represented by City, it shall immediately inform the City of this and shall not
proceed with further work under this Agreement until written instructions are received
from the City.
Section 8. Time of Essence.
Time is of the essence in the performance of this Agreement.
Section 9. Compliance with law.
Consultant shall comply with all applicable laws, ordinances, codes and
regulations of federal, state and local government.
Section 10. Conflicts of Interest.
Consultant covenants that it presently has no interest and shall not acquire any
interest, direct or indirect, which would conflict in any manner or degree with the
performance of the services contemplated by this Agreement. No person having such
interest shall be employed by or associated with Consultant.
Section 11. Copies of Work Product.
At the completion of the work, Consultant shall have delivered to City at least one
(1) copy of any final reports and/or notes or drawings containing Consultant's findings,
conclusions, and recommendations with any supporting documentation. All reports
submitted to the City shall be in reproducible format, or in the format otherwise
approved by the City in writing.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 12. Ownership of Documents.
All reports, information, data and exhibits prepared or assembled by Consultant
in connection with the performance of its services pursuant to this Agreement are
confidential to the extent permitted by law, and Consultant agrees that they shall not be
made available to any individual or organization without prior written consent of the City.
All such reports, information, data, and exhibits shall be the property of the City and
shall be delivered to the City upon demand without additional costs or expense to the
City. The City acknowledges such documents are instruments of Consultant's
professional services. In the course of performance hereunder, Consultant may use
(and may authorize the City's personnel to use) certain Consultant Intellectual Property
to assist in engagement completion. The City shall not have or obtain any right or title
to or interest in such Consultant Intellectual Property (or in any modifications or
enhancements thereto). Consultant makes no express or implied warranties of any kind
regarding the Consultant Intellectual Property.
Section 13. Indemni .
To the fullest extent permitted by law, Consultant agrees to protect, defend, and
hold harmless the City and its elective and appointive boards, officers, agents, and
employees from any and all claims, liabilities, expenses, or damages of any nature,
including attorneys' fees, for injury or death of any person, or damages of any nature,
including interference with use of property, arising out of, or in any way connected with
the negligence, recklessness and/or intentional wrongful conduct of Consultant,
Consultant's agents, officers, employees, subcontractors, or independent contractors
hired by Consultant in the performance of the Agreement. The only exception to
Consultant's responsibility to protect, defend, and hold harmless the City, is due to the
negligence, recklessness and/or wrongful conduct of the City, or any of its elective or
appointive boards, officers, agents, or employees.
Consultant's liability for any matter arising under this Agreement or from any
transaction contemplated herein, including without limitation the provision of the
Services, shall not exceed the actual amount paid by an insurer as a result of any claim
made with respect to such matter under Consultant's insurance policies (the "Liability
Cap"). The City acknowledges that the Liability Cap is a material term upon which
Consultant has relied in entering into this Agreement and that Consultant would not
have entered into this Agreement in the absence of such provision.
Section 14. Acceptance and Release
The City shall be deemed to have accepted all Services in a given Phase and the work
product resulting therefrom upon the City's payment of the invoice received from
Consultant in respect of the Services. Upon such acceptance, the Government shall be
deemed to have released the Consultant from any additional work undersuch Phase of
the Services.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 3
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 15. Insurance.
On or before beginning any of the services or work called for by any term of this
Agreement, Consultant, at its own cost and expense, shall carry, maintain for the
duration of the agreement, and provide proof thereof that is acceptable to the City, the
insurance specified below with insurers and under forms of insurance satisfactory in all
respects to the City. Consultant shall not allow any subcontractor to commence work
on any subcontract until all insurance required of the Consultant has also been obtained
for the subcontractor. Insurance required herein shall be provided by Admitted Insurers
in good standing with the State of California and having a minimum Best's Guide Rating
of A- Class VII or better.
15.1 Comprehensive General Liability.
Throughout the term of this Agreement, Consultant shall maintain in full
force and effect Comprehensive General Liability coverage in an amount not less than
one million dollars per occurrence ($1,000,000.00), combined single limit coverage for
risks associated with the work contemplated by this agreement. If a Commercial
General Liability Insurance form or other form with a general aggregate limit is used,
either the general aggregate limit shall apply separately to the work to be performed
under this agreement or the general aggregate limit shall be at least twice the required
occurrence limit.
15.2 Comprehensive Automobile Liability.
Throughout the term of this Agreement, Consultant shall maintain in full
force and effect Comprehensive Automobile Liability coverage, including owned, hired
and non -owned vehicles in an amount not less than one million dollars per occurrence
($1,000,000.00).
15.3 Worker's Compensation.
If Consultant intends to employ employees to perform services under this
Agreement, Consultant shall obtain and maintain, during the term of this Agreement,
Worker's Compensation Employer's Liability Insurance in the statutory amount as
required by state law.
15.4 Proof of Insurance Requirements/Endorsement.
Prior to beginning any work under this Agreement, Consultant shall submit
the insurance certificates, including the deductible or self -retention amount, and an
additional insured endorsement naming City, its officers, employees, agents, and
volunteers as additional insureds as respects each of the following: Liability arising out
of activities performed by or on behalf of Consultant, including the insured's general
supervision of Consultant; products and completed operations of Consultant; premises
owned, occupied or used by Consultant; or automobiles owned, leased, hired, or
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
4
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
borrowed by Consultant. The coverage shall contain no special limitations on the scope
of protection afforded City, its officers, employees, agents, or volunteers.
15.5 Errors and Omissions Coverage
Throughout the term of this Agreement, Consultant shall maintain Errors
and Omissions Coverage (professional liability coverage) in an amount of not less than
One Million Dollars ($1,000,000). Prior to beginning any work under this Agreement,
Consultant shall submit an insurance certificate to the City's General Counsel for
certification that the insurance requirements of this Agreement have been satisfied.
15.6 Notice of Cancellation/Termination of Insurance.
The above policy/policies shall not terminate, nor shall they be cancelled,
nor the coverages reduced, until after thirty (30) days' written notice is given to City,
except that ten (10) days' notice shall be given if there is a cancellation due to failure to
pay a premium.
15.7 Terms of Compensation.
Consultant shall not receive any compensation until all insurance
provisions have been satisfied.
15.8 Notice to Proceed.
Consultant shall not proceed with any work under this Agreement until the
City has issued a written "Notice to Proceed" verifying that Consultant has complied
with all insurance requirements of this Agreement.
Section 16. Termination.
City shall have the right to terminate this Agreement without cause by giving
thirty (30) days' advance written notice of termination to Consultant.
In addition, this Agreement may be terminated by any party for cause by
providing ten (10) days' notice to the other party of a material breach of contract. If the
other party does not cure the breach of contract, then the agreement may be terminated
subsequent to the ten (10) day cure period.
Section 17. Notice.
All notices shall be personally delivered or mailed to the below listed addresses,
or to such other addresses as may be designated by written notice. These addresses
shall be used for delivery of service of process:
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
To City: City of San Juan Capistrano
32400 Paseo Adelanto
San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675
Attn: Cindy Russell
To Consultant: Government Finance Officers Association
203 N LaSalle, Suite 2700
Chicago, Illinois 60601
Attn: Anne Spray Kinney
Section 18. Attorneys' Fees.
If any action at law or in equity is necessary to enforce or interpret the terms of
this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees, costs
and necessary disbursements in addition to any other relief to which he may be entitled.
Section 19. Dispute Resolution.
In the event of a dispute arising between the parties regarding performance or
interpretation of this Agreement, the dispute shall be resolved by binding arbitration
under the auspices of the Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Service ("JAMS").
Section 20. Publications
As an educational, nonprofit, professional membership association, Consultant
reserves the right to publish non -confidential documents describing the results of, or
created during, the Services performed under this Agreement. Consultant will not
publish any item with the name of the City without obtaining the prior written consent of
the City.
Section 21. Entire Arareement.
This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding and agreement between the
parties and supersedes all previous negotiations between them pertaining to the subject
matter thereof.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement.
CITY OF SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO
By:
Dave Adams, City Manager
GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
By:
Jeffrey L. Esser, CEO and Executive Director
ATTEST:
City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
City Attorney
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 7
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
EXHIBIT "A"
Statement of Work
Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning
City of San Juan Capistrano
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
1 Methodology, Staffing, and Workplan ..................................................................... 10
1.1 The Long Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning Team 10
1.2 The Work Plan 11
2 Project Assumptions................................................................................................. 22
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
1. Methodology, Staffing, and Workplan
1.1. The Long Term Vision and Strategic Business Planning
Team
I.I.I. Organizational Chart
Strategic Plan Steering Committee
City's Project Leader
Anne Kinney Shayne Kavai
Strategic & Business ----- Financial Plan
GFOA Financial '
GFOA Strategic & Analysts
I
Business Plan
Analysts
----------------------------
1.1.2. Duties of Team Members
City of San Juan Capistrano Team Members
1. Strategic Plan Steering Committee
a. Review work product
b. Sponsor project
2. Project Leader
a. Provide resources as needed
b. Enable staff to accomplish tasks
c. Model behaviors needed for successful planning
d. Encourage other team members
3. Project Coordinator
a. Manage day-to-day scheduling and work requirements
4. Financial Staff
a. Participate in financial analysis meetings
b. Gather data
c. Conduct forecasting
d. Conduct analysis
5. Staff for Strategic & Business Plan
a. Complete business plans
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
GFOA Team Members:
1. Anne Kinney, Project Manager and Strategic & Business Plan Manager
a. Work with steering committee and project leader on overall project
direction
b. Facilitate meetings
c. Interview stakeholders
d.. Conduct analysis
e. Coordinate tasks related to Strategic Business Plan and performance
measurement
£ Facilitate meetings
g. Interview stakeholders
h. Conduct analysis
3. Shayne Kavanagh, Financial Planning Manager
a. Coordinate tasks related to financial planning
b. Facilitate meetings
c. Interview stakeholders
d. Conduct analysis
4. David Buma, Facilitation Assistance
a. Assist with focus group facilitation as required
7. Mike Mucha, Lead Strategic/Business Plan Analyst
a. Assist Strategic & Business Plan manager as required
8. Brenda Boyle, Financial Plan Analyst
a. Assist financial plan manager as required
Third -party Team Members:
1. Chris Swanson, founder of Government Finance Research Group
a. MuniCast configuration and data loading
1.2. The Work Tasks
Task # Description
Responsibilities
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
II
Designate City Project Leader and
A
Manager; Define project success
A.i
Designate project leader
Assist
Lead
A.ii
Designate project manager
Assist
Lead
Coordinate meeting to establish & clarify
A.iii
project expectations
Assist
Lead
Conduct meeting to establish & clarify
A.iv
project expectations
Lead
Participate
Develop project expectations agreement
A.v
document
Lead
Assist
A.vi
Develop project plan and timeline
Lead
Assist
Informal project expectations agreement
and formal project plan and timeline (in
Deliverable 1A
MS Excel or MS Project)
Lead
Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
II
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
12
Establish a Project Steering Team and
Task B
supporting teams
B.i
Designate project Steering Team
Assist
Lead
Develop requirements for team
B.ii
membership
Lead
Assist
B.iii
Write team charter
Lead
Assist
B.iv
Identify supporting teams and structure
Lead
Assist
B.v
Identify supporting team members
Assist
Lead
B.vii
Coordinate meeting to accomplish tasks
Assist
Lead
B.viii
Conduct meeting to accomplish tasks
Lead
Participate
Create Project Steering Team Charter
Deliverable 1B
and develop structure of supporting teams
Lead
Assist
Task C
Community involvement strategy
CJ
Identify primary stakeholders and groups
Assist
Lead
Identify information desired from
CA
stakeholders
Lead
Assist
Identify timing for when information is
C.iii
needed
Lead
Assist
Identify best tools for engaging
C.iv
stakeholders
Lead
Assist
C.v
Implement tools (excepting focus groups)
None
Lead
C.vi
Coordinate meeting to accomplish tasks
Assist
Lead
C.viii
Conduct meeting to accomplish tasks
Lead
Participate
Community involvement strategy
Deliverable 1C
document
Lead
Review
Phase 2. Create
Mission/Vision
Task A
Gather stakeholder input
Interview key stakeholders inside City
AJ
government
Lead
Participate
Establish an approach and schedule for
A.ii
conducting surveys and focus groups.
Lead
Assist
Identify key survey objectives and
A.iii
questions
Lead
Assist
Design detailed survey format and
A.iv
conduct survey
None
Lead
A.v
Develop summary of survey results
None
Lead
Summary memo of stakeholder interviews
Deliverable 2A
and fesusgreups
Lead
Review
Task B
Develop preliminary mission/vision
Develop "straw -man" mission/vision
B.i
based on stakeholder interviews
Lead
Assist
Interview key stakeholders outside City
B.ii
government
Lead
Assist
Refine "straw -man" missiontvision for best
fit possible to City, before focus groups
B.iii
are conducted.
Participate
Lead
Deliverable 26
Strawman mission/vision statement
Lead
Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
12
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Task C
Focus Groups
Review background materials related to
previous City planning efforts and to
better understand the San Juan
Capistrano's unique public policy
C.i
environment and culture.
Lead
None
Develop a format, agenda, questions and
other materials to be used in the focus
groups, with the City's input and
CA
feedback.
Lead
Participate
Identify the types of participants to be
C.iii
included in the focus groups
Lead
Assist
Recruit individuals for focus groups.
GFOA can give feedback on ideas City
C.iv
has for recruits.
Participate
Lead
Facilitate the focus group sessions and
C.v
record information gathered
Lead
None
Synthesize information gathered into a
format useful for strategic planning
purposes and prepare a written summary
C.vi
of focus group results
Lead
None
Present the results of focus groups held to
the project steering team for feedback and
C.vii
validation
Lead
Participate
Prepare a brief report of the focus group
results for the focus group participants to
C.viii
keep them engaged
Lead
Participate
Deliverable 2C
Results of focus groups report
Lead
Participate
Task D
Mission and Vision Workshop
Design workshop format, agenda,
D.i
structure
Lead
Assist
Coordinate workshop scheduling,
D.ii
logistical support
Assist
Lead
D.iii
Conduct workshop
Lead
Participate
Facilitate deliberation on mission/vision
D.iv
statement
Lead
Participate
D.v
Articulte mission/vision
Participate
Lead
Record deliberation and mission/vision
D.vi
articulated by City
Lead
None
D.vii
Formally appprove mission/vision
None
Lead
Deliverable 2D
Summary memo of workshop results
Lead
Review
PhaF,e 3. Analysis
Task A
Financial Analysis
A.i
Draft core values for financial sustainablity
Lead
Assist
A.ii
Review and approve core values
None
Lead
Review existing policies, make
suggestions for improvement and for new
A.iii
policies to support core values
Lead
Review
Develop new policy statements, as
A.iv
needed
Assist
Lead
A.v
Approve new and improved policies
None
Lead
AM
Provide template for Municast data
Lead
None
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
13
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
collection
A.vii
Collect and clean data for Municast
None
Lead
A.viii
Load data into Municast
Lead
None
Conduct meeting to review major
assumtions and qualitative factors
A.ix
influencing revenue'& expenditures
Lead
Participate
Determine how assumptions will be
A.x
expressed in Municast
Lead
Assist
Make forecast. The City will take a lead
role with GFOA's assistance in Municast
configuration and training, revenue &
expenditure assumptions/analysis, and
refining of the model. The City will
A.xi
ultimately make and own the forecast.
Participate
Lead
Determine debt indicators to be used for
A.xii
analysis
Lead
Assist
A.xiii
Provide data on current debt levels
None
Lead
Provide data on likely future capital
A.xiv
projects
None
Lead
Conduct high-level assessment of debt
A.xv
position
Lead
Assist
Identify major imbalances in financial
A.xvi
position
Lead
Assist
Compare mission & vision with existing
plans. Determine financial impact of other
plans (land use, general plan). The City
will take the lead role, especially in
A.xvii
assessing the impact of the land use plan
Assist
Lead
Develop Financial Analysis Report. City
will be actively involved in deciding what
issues to focus on, gathering data, and
A.xv
contributing its own analysis of issues
Lead
Assist
Deliverable 3A
Financial Analysis Report
Lead
Review
Task B
Environmental Analysis
Identify need for additional stakeholder
B.i
interviews
Lead
Assist
Conduct up to four hours of additional
B.ii
interviews
Lead
Participate
B.iii
Conduct additional interviews
None
Lead
Review other City plans and identify any
divergence from these plans that may be
anticipated as a result of this planning
B.iv
process
Lead
None
B.v
Provide "menu" of financial indicators
Lead
None
B.vi
Select indicators
Assist
Lead
B.vii
Identify up to 5 comparable jurisdictions
Lead
Assist
B.viii
Perform comparisons using CAFR data
Lead
None
B.ix
Gather historical data for indicators
None
Lead
B.x
Construct up to ten financial indicators
Lead
Assist
B.xi
Construct additional financial indicators
None
Lead
Summary report of environmental
analyses including recommendations for
Deliverable 3B
financial strategies
Lead
Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
IG
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
15
Schedule and coordinate workshop. Invite
Phase 4. Issues &
Strategies Validation
A.iv
Two day planning retreat/workshop with
Task A
City staff and City Council
Am
Get early feedback from Project Steering
A.i
Committee on plan elements to date Participate Lead
A.ii
Create workshop format & presentation Lead Review
Lead
Identify need for and develop other
supporting documentation for workshop.
The City may have a lead role in
Deliverable 4A
developing certain supporting documents,
A.iii
if GFOA and the City agree as such. Lead Assist
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
15
Schedule and coordinate workshop. Invite
A.iv
participants and address other logistics
Assist
Lead
Am
Conduct workshop
Lead
Participate
AM
Write summary of workshop
Lead
None
Summary memo recapping workshop
Deliverable 4A
issues and conclusions
Lead
Review
Task B
Focus Groups
Develop a format, agenda, questions and
other materials to be used in the focus
B.ii
groups
Lead
Participate
Facilitate the focus group sessions and
B.v
record information gathered
Lead
None
Synthesize information gathered into a
format useful for strategic planning
purposes and prepare a written summary
B.vi
of focus group results
Lead
None
Present the results of focus groups held to
the project steering team for feedback and
B.vii
validation
Lead
Participate
Prepare a brief report of the focus group
results for the focus group participants to
B.viii
keep them engaged
Lead
Participate
Deliverable 4B
Results of focus groups report
Lead
Participate
Phase 5. Business
Planning & Performance Measurement
Business planning and performance
Task A
measurement template development
Develop business planning and
AJ
performance measurement templates
Lead
Review
Begin to develop information required by
A.ii
templates
Review
Lead
Deliverable 5A
Deliver templates
Lead
Review
Busines planning & performance
Task B
measurement development
Develop workshop/training format for city
B.i
staff
Lead
Assist
B.ii
Conduct workshop
Lead
Participate
Coordinate workshop and provide
B.iii
logistical support
Assist
Lead
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
15
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
B.iv City staff complete business plans Review Lead
Deliverable 5B Workshop delivered Lead Participate
Task C
Business plan consultation
Provide up to 15 consultant hours to
C.i
support business planning
Lead
None
C.ii
Decide how hours are to be used
Assist
Lead
C.iii
Authorize use of hours
None
Lead
Up to 15 hours of consultant support
Deliverable 5C
provided
Lead
None
Phase 6. Drafting
the Plan
Task A
Committee validation
Develop outline for Strategic Business
AJ
Plan
Lead
Assist
Conduct meeting to review progress and
validate direction and Strategic Business
Plan outline and contents of staffs
A.ii
business plans
Lead
Participate
A.iii
Steering committee issues validation
None
Lead
A.iv
Coordinate meeting
Assist
Lead
Deliverable 6A
Outline for Strategic Business Plan
Lead
Review
Task B
Draft Plan
Write and assemble full plan (compile
business plans). The City will need to take
a strong assist role and may lead the
development of certain sections, where
B.i
deeper, hands-on experience is important.
Lead
Assist
Make copies as may be required for
B.ii
distribution to stakeholders
None
Lead
Deliverable 6B
Draft Plan
Lead
Review
Task C
Forecast update and refinement
Determine scenarios and issues arising
through planning process to incorporate
C.1
into forecast
Assist
Lead
Update Municast to incorporate scenarios
C.ii
and issues
Lead
Assist
C.iii
Update and refine forecasts
Participate
Lead
Deliverable 6C
Municast model updated
Lead
Assist
Task D
Final Plan
Submit plan for review and comment to
D.i
stakeholder groups
Participate
Lead
DA
Modify plan as required
Participate
Lead
Design format for public meeting to review
D.iii
plan
Assist
Lead
Conduct meeting. GFOA will actively
assist in planning the presentation or can
D.iv
lead the presentation
Assist
Lead
D.v
Modify plan as required
Participate
Lead
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
IM
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Develop any special publishing format for
business plan, including binding, graphics,
D.vii etc. None Lead
D.viii Print/Publish final business plan None Lead
Deliverable 6D Public Meeting held Assist Lead
Designing link between business plan and
Task A
budget
GFOA will provide approximately 25 hours
of assistance for this task. Possible
detailed activities are are below.
Responsiblities can vary based on City's
direction for use of hours. Responsiblities
and tasks can be finalized as the project
AJ
progresses.
Assist
Lead
A.ii
Review current budget process
Assist
Lead
Design linkage between major forecast
assumptions and budget development
A.iii
assumptions
Assist
Lead
A.iv
Design budget accountability mechanisms
Assist
Lead
Am
Design budget request process and forms
Assist
Lead
A.vi
Authorize use of hours
None
Lead
A.vii
Implementation of budget links
None
Lead
Deliverable 7A
25 Hours of assistance provided
Lead
None
Phase 8. D.
Task A
Project review
Review project with Strategic Plan
AJ
Steering Committee
Lead
Assist
Deliverable 8A
Review conducted
Lead
Assist
Develop on-going Strategic Business Plan
Task B
process
Develop on-going Strategic Business Plan
BJ
process
Lead
Assist
B.ii
Depict process in flow -chart process map
Lead
None
Deliverable 8B
Flow -chart process map
Lead
Review
Transition to the Steering Committee for
Task C
implementation
Define committee's responsibility,
accountability, authority, and resoruces
C.i
for implementing the plan
Assist
Lead
Develop charter for Steering Committee's
CA
implementation work
Lead
Participate
C.iii
Execution of implementation strategies
None
Lead
Deliverable 8C
Charter for the Steering Committee
Lead
Review
Note that GFOA provides electronic copies of deliverables and other work in Word, Excel,
and/or PDF formats
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
17
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
1.2.1. Deliverable Expectations
Phase 1— Project Start-up
IA. Designate a project leader and project manager and define project success. GFOA will help
develop a Project Expectations Agreement (informal) which will be approved by the Project
Leader or other designated City staff. A formal project plan and timeline will also be finalized at
this point.
1 B. Establish a Project Steering Team and supporting teams. GFOA will write a charter to
clarify responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources of the Steering Team and
supporting teams.
I C. Community Involvement Strategy. GFOA will deliver a community involvement strategy
document that includes a timetable, mechanisms for community involvement and
communication, specific tools and techniques to involve the community, and a strategy to engage
the local media.
Phase 2 — Creating the Mission and Vision
2A. Summary of Stakeholder Input. GFOA will interview key stakeholders both inside and
outside of city government and will produce a summary report of information obtained from
interviews, focus groups, and other stakeholder input mechanisms the City chooses to use (e.g.,
telephone surveys).
2B. Straw man mission/vision. GFOA and the City will develop a "straw man" mission/vision
that can be presented to participants in public engagement forums, particularly focus groups.
The intent is to provide the participants with a starting point and something to react to.
2C. Results of focus groups report. This is a brief report to describe the results of the focus
groups. The report will provide a more direct recounting of the focus groups' input as well as
broader themes synthesized from GFOA's overview of all of the groups.
21). Mission and Vision Workshop Summary Memo. GFOA will facilitate a public workshop to
present stakeholder input and develop a mission and vision statement. GFOA will provide a
format, supporting tools, and a brief memo of results. The City has the lead role in developing a
mission and vision with GFOA support throughout the process.
Phase 3 - Analysis
3A. Financial Analysis Report. GFOA will conduct an analysis of the City's financial situation
and provide the results in a Financial Analysis Report. At minimum, the analysis is to include the
following activities:
• Financial policy review
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
18
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
■ Preliminary revenue/expenditure forecasting (the City will begin to load data into the
Municast model and begin developing forecasts as early in the project as possible)
■ Debt analysis
■ Imbalance analysis
■ Analysis of financial impact on and of existing plans
3B. Environmental Analysis Summary. GFOA will work with the City to conduct a
comprehensive environmental analysis to identify the most important issues facing the City of
San Juan Capistrano over a five-, 10-, and 20 -year period. In order to develop this list of issues,
the environmental scan will identify 1) internal strengths and weaknesses, 2) external threats and
opportunities, and 3) community resources the City might take advantage of GFOA will produce
a brief summary of the environmental analysis that contains key service, financial, and other
issues and the City's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and challenges. This summary will
also document any divergences from existing plans, such as the general plan and the land use
plan.
Phase 4 — Issues and Strategies Validation
4A. Planning Retreat Summary Memo. GFOA will design and conduct a two-day
workshop/retreat to present a draft set of issues as well as preliminary recommendations on
strategies, overall objectives, and a first cut of an action plan. The workshop/retreat will involve
City staff on the first day and City Council members and executives on the second day. GFOA
will design and facilitate the workshops, provide documents, and produce a written summary of
workshop output and outcomes. During the retreat, any divergence from existing plans will be
addressed.
4B. Results of focus groups report. This is a brief report to describe the results of the second set
of focus groups. The report will provide a more direct recounting of the focus groups' input as
well as broader themes synthesized from GFOA's overview of all of the groups.
Phase 5 — Business Planning and Performance Measurement
5A. Business Plan Templates. GFOA will develop and deliver a set of business planning and
performance measurement templates to help City staff develop the information required for a
business plan. The templates will be designed to produce an "issue driven" business plan, rather
than one focused on departments or other functional divisions of the City.
513. Business Planning & Performance Measurement Development Workshop. GFOA will work
with City staff to develop the business plan and performance measures. GFOA's and the City's
objective will be to train staff to create business plans. GFOA will deliver a workshop or other
mechanism for developing business pians, performance measures, and targets. The City has the
lead role in business plan development with GFOA support throughout the process.
5C. Business Plan Consultation. GFOA can make itself available on a per -hour basis to provide
consultation and staff augmentation to the City, as required to support the completion of the
business plan. GFOA will work with the City to support the completion of the business plan for
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
up to 15 consultant hours.
Phase 6 — Drafting the Strategic Business Plan
6A. Outline for Strategic Business Plan. A meeting will be held with the Strategic Plan Steering
Committee to review the materials and progress made to this point. The Committee's validation
will allow the Strategic Business Plan to be drafted. GFOA will provide a proposed outline for
the Strategic Business Plan and facilitate a meeting to validate direction and Strategic Business
Plan contents.
B. Draft Plan. GFOA and City staff will cooperate to finalize a draft of the Strategic Business
Plan. The Strategic Business Plan will be based on the strategic, operational, and financial
elements produced throughout the project.
C. Municast Model Updated The information provided through the foregoing phase will enable
the City and GFOA to refine the revenue and expenditure forecast. It is anticipated that the City
will lead this forecast update, but GFOA will advise how to best incorporate new information
into the Municast model. GFOA will update the Municast model to incorporate assumptions
needed for the City to revise the forecast.
D. Public Meeting to Present Plan. After the draft plan is delivered, there will be a review and
comment period followed by a public meeting to present the plan. GFOA will help the City
design the meeting and will participate in the meeting.
Phase 7 — Linking to the Budget Process
7A, 25 hours of Consultation to Design Link between Business Plan and Budget. GFOA will
work with City staff on a process for assuring that the plan becomes the basis for the budget — or,
at minimum, is a critical input to the budgeting process. GFOA will work with City for up to 25
hours to advise on linkages, develop forms, etc.
Phase 8 — Documentation and Wrap -Up
8A. Project Review Conducted GFOA will review the project with the Strategic Plan Steering
Committee. Taking the time to reflect on the project and identify what aspects of the project the
City wants to save, delete, and change going forward is the first step towards developing an on-
going Strategic Business Planning cycle.
8B. On-going Strategic Business Plan Process Map. GFOA will propose a final on-going
Strategic Business Planning model for the City that can be maintained independent of consultant
support. GFOA will deliver a flow -chart process map to depict the final recommended process,
including the links into the budget process.
8C. Charter for Strategic Plan Steering Committee's Implementation Role. GFOA will help the
Committee transition to plan implementation. GFOA will help the City develop a charter to
define the Committee's responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources for the
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 20
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
implementation of the plan.
1.2.2. Timeline
Jul AugSet Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb March
Phase I -ProStart-U
A. Designate Leader
B. Establish Teams
C. Involvement Strategy
Focus Group
Phase 2 - Create Mission/Vision
A. Stakeholder Input
B. Mission & Vision Workshop
Phase 3 - Analysis
A. Financial Analysis
B. Environmental Analysis
Phase 4 - Issues & Strategies Validation
A. Planning Retreat
Phase S - Business Planning & Performance Measurement
A. Templates Developed
B. Plan & Measures Developed
C. Plan Consultation
Phase 6 - Drafting the Plan
A. Committee Validation
B. Draft Plan
C. Forecast Update
D. Final Plan
Phase 7 - Link to BudXd
A. Designing Link
Phase 8 - Documentation & Wrap U
A. Project Review
B. On -Going Planning Process
C. Transition to Implementation
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 21
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
2. Project Assumptions
2.1. Listing of Project Assumptions
• City staff provides data and participates in interview and other activities requested by GFOA.
• A single point of contact from the City is identified;
• GFOA undertakes no more than the indicated number of on-site trips within the price
included in this proposal.
o Trip #1 - Interview stakeholders on defining success and perception of environment,
meet with Strategic Plan Steering Committee, conduct technical planning workshops
(forecasting, environmental modeling, etc.). 3 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #2 — Focus group facilitation #1 — 4 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #3 — Conduct mission workshop, 1 day, 2 consultants
o Trip #4 — Strategic issues retreat, 2 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #5 — Business plan workshop, 2 days, 2 consultants
o Trip #6 — Present draft plan to committee, 1 day, 2 consultants
o Trip #7 — Present draft plan to public, 1 day, 2 consultants
o Trip #9 — Focus group facilitation #2 — 4 days, 2 consultants
• GFOA's role in the development of a plan is consultative and advisory in nature. The City
will play an important role in data collection, will participate as partners in plan
development, and will make any final decisions on strategy and direction.
• The project scope is not expanded beyond the items listed in the proposal at the proposed
(discounted) price, unless so negotiated with the GFOA.
• As an educational, nonprofit, professional membership association, GFOA reserves the right
to publish non -confidential documents describing the results of, or created during, the
services described in this scope of work. GFOA will not publish any item with the name of
the City of San Juan Capistrano without obtaining prior written consent of the government.
• GFOA is partnering with the Government Finance Research Group to provide the MuniCast
financial analysis and sensitivity analysis system. GFOA's role is not to provide forecasts of
revenue and expenditures on which the City can rely. The City will have responsibility for
collecting data to be included in MuniCast. Data elements include:
o Historic annual revenues, expenditures, other sources and uses, beginning FY1999-
2000, for all City appropriated funds
o Current year budgeted or estimated (if available) data
o Historic budgeted/estimated fund balances
o Debt service and other liabilities (e.g. retirement, healthcare, etc.)
o Staff positions data for same time period
o Baseline and alternative forecast scenarios, extending out to 2030 (or other fiscal
period indicated by City), to be jointly developed by City and GFOA team
• GFOA develops its reports to be clear and concise. We focus on brevity in order to make our
reports accessible to the public and elected officials.
• GFOA submits deliverables and other documents electronically in Microsoft Word, Excel,
and or PDF formats.
• GFOA is a non-profit membership association made up of members like the City of San Juan
Capistrano, and therefore we have no owners' equity to fall back on. Therefore, GFOA's
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 22
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
liability and indemnification under any agreement reached with the City must be limited to
the extent of fees paid by GFOA's insurance coverage. (Please note that this limitation would
require an amendment to the City's standard Personal Services Agreement.)
• 12 focus groups would be facilitated by GFOA during initial issue identification.
• The same 12 focus groups would be facilitated by GFOA during strategy development.
• Each of the foregoing focus group meetings will take place within a 1 week period so that
GFOA consultants can make one trip to conduct the focus groups.
• The focus groups would last between 2.5 and 3 hours each.
• The City will develop a report after the second set of focus groups to let the focus groups
know how their input impacted the report and to engage them for plan execution.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
23
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
EXHIBIT "B"
THE RESEARCH AND CONSULTING CENTER
GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
January 30, 2008
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
24
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Table of Contents
Section1 - Cover Letter....................................................................................................
26
Section 2 - Background and Approach.............................................................................
28
A. GFOA's Understanding of the City's Project..........................................................
28
13. Objectives to be Accomplished................................................................................
28
C. The Work to be Done...............................................................................................
29
D. Out -of -Scope Activities...........................................................................................
35
Section 3 - Timetable/Schedule of Required Tasks..........................................................
35
Section 4 - Identify the Team............................................................................................
36
A. The Proposing Firm................................................................................................
36
B. Contact Information.................................................................................................
37
C. Location of the Work...............................................................................................
37
D. Organization Chart ...................................................................................................
37
E. Proposed Team Members.........................................................................................
38
Section 5 - Qualifications and Related Experience...........................................................
38
A. GFOA's Strategic and Financial Planning Expertise ...............................................
38
B. Recent Directly Related Experience........................................................................
39
C. Key Personnel..........................................................................................................
40
D. Other Public Entities Served....................................................................................
43
Section 6 - Other Information...........................................................................................
43
A. Optional Services.....................................................................................................
43
B. About Our Discount.................................................................................................
44
C. Key Assumptions.....................................................................................................
44
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
25
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 1 - Cover Letter
January 30, 2008
Cindy Russell
Assistant City Manager
City of San Juan Capistrano
City Manager's Office
32400 Paseo Adelanto
San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675
Dear Ms. Russell:
The Govemment Finance Officers Association (GFOA) is pleased to present a proposal to assist
the City of San Juan Capistrano with the development of a long-term vision and strategic
business plan. GFOA has significant experience providing these types of consulting services and
we have completed extensive research on best practices in strategic planning, long-term financial
planning, and performance measurement among our 17,500 members.
We are excited about the chance to work with the City of San Juan Capistrano on this project.
The key elements of our proposal include:
• An Integrated Approach to Planning, Goal Setting, and Budgeting. GFOA's
research on best practices is consistent with the City's desire to create a long-term
strategic, financial and operational context for preparing annual budgets, and for using
performance measurement to link the various components of such a system. Our goal for
this project is to concurrently work to assure that individual tasks are completed on time
and are of a high quality and also to assure that all the tasks and products, whether short -
or long-term, are faithful to the overall direction that is set in the mission, vision, and
long term strategies that are developed. Our focus throughout the project will be to work
with the City to ask and answer the following questions:
o Strategic: What are the most important "big picture" strategic issues and concems
facing the City over the long-term?
o Operational: What actions will the City take to address these issues? What is the
schedule for these activities? Who is responsible? How will progress be measured
and accountability maintained?
o Financial: What are the long -run financial implications of the strategic issues and
operational plans? How can the City maintain financial sustainability over the
long-term?
• An Approach that Assures that the Financial Situation is Systematically Addressed.
Too often, organizations prepare strategic plans in virtual isolation from an understanding
of the available financial resources. Elegant strategic plans, strategies, and service targets
may be created, but after the planning process has ended, these organizations then
struggle to fund goals that may already be publicly announced. Using expertise in long-
term financial planning, and leveraging information from our membership base of 17,500
finance professionals, GFOA's approach provides early and equal attention to the
financial situation in planning. GFOA is the leading authority on long-term financial
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
26
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
planning for local government. GFOA published the popular book Financing the Future:
Long -Term Financial Planning for Local Government enclosed with this proposal) and
has provided advice to many of our member governments on this subject. Further, GFOA
staff has authored articles in numerous journals, including Government Finance Review,
Public Management, School Business Affairs, and School Planning and Management,
and has spoken at conferences and training sessions nationwide.
A Long -Term, Implementation -Ready Approach. Our proposal is designed so that
strategies and operational plans are ready to go for the City's next budget while at the
same time enabling the City to carry forward the Strategic Business Planning process
independent of future consultant support. The best plan if not properly implemented is
simply a costly theoretical exercise. Our approach provides for a transition to
implementation, if possible before our engagement has ended, by working with City staff
to design implementation plans and link these plans to the City's budget.
An Inclusive and Consensus -Driven Approach. GFOA believes public participation in
strategic planning is essential. Our approach will engage the community to be real
contributors to the plan at multiple stages of the process. The most powerful means for
implementing a plan is if the stakeholders of the plan strongly support it. A plan
development approach that builds consensus among stakeholders will result in a plan that
garners a wide base of support.
Municast. GFOA will provide the City with the Municast computerized revenue and
expenditure forecasting software system. Municast is a Microsoft Excel -based tool that is
currently in use by over 20 California municipalities. Municast is powerful and easy to
use. The City can learn more about Municast at www.municast.com.
If you have any questions regarding this proposal, please contact either me using the contact
information below, or Shayne Kavanagh, at 312-578-2276 or skavanagh@gfoa.org.
Sincerely,
Anne Spray Kinney
Director, GFOA Research and Consulting Center
312-977-9700
akinneyAgfoa,org
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
27
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Section 2 - Background and Approach
This section includes: A) Our understanding of the City's project; B) The objectives to be
accomplished; C) The work to be done; and D) Out -of -scope activities.
A. GFOA's Understanding of the City's Project
The City of San Juan Capistrano has begun to transition from a growing city to a more mature,
"built -out" community. The vast majority of available land has been developed (approximately
90% in GFOA's understanding). This means that the City will not be able to count on new
revenue from growth to the extent it did in the past. Also, a number of indicators point to the
United States entering a period of recession or, if not officially a recession, then at minimum an
economic downturn. The City wishes to take steps now to maintain its solid financial position
through its transition to a fully developed community and through economic downturns.
The City has developed a number of long-term plans, such as a redevelopment plans,
water and sewer master plans, and an open space needs assessment. However, the City has
identified the need for an overarching strategic vision and a long-term vision that is aligned with
financial capacity. Therefore, the City has initiated this project to develop a strategic plan that is
supported by a solid long-term financial analysis, detailed implementation strategies, and
performance measures. GFOA terms this a "Strategic Business Plan."
It is our understanding that the City would like the Strategic Business Plan to provide the
context for its annual budget process. Currently, the City's budget process begins in December;
however, the City anticipates that this schedule may change as a result of the work done on this
project.
B. Objectives to be Accomplished
Objective 1: The City has articulated a clear and concise mission and vision for the community
that is consensus -based. (A mission and vision statement will be developed early in the project
so that it can be used as a yardstick and reference point for the remainder of the project.)
Objective 2: The City has created a written Strategic Business Plan that articulates critical
strategic and fiscal issues, includes objectives and strategies for addressing these issues, and
links these to programs, services, and activities related to daily operations and consequently to
the budget process via performance measures that will be used to gauge progress. (The plan will
be based on a comprehensive environmental analysis that includes a thorough financial
situational analysis.)
Objective 3: The City's Strategic Business Plan contains a long-term financial perspective and
provides strategies for maintaining fiscal stability. (The plan includes an assessment of the
city's financial structure, projects revenues and expenditures over the long term, identifies
potential structural and cyclical imbalances, and proposes courses of action for addressing them.)
Objective 4: The City has the appropriate knowledge base, tools, and processes for regularly
reviewing its financial situation, including a financial trend monitoring system and a
computerized financial modeling and forecasting system. (GFOA's approach provides templates
and tools that can be adopted by the City and focuses on working with City staff throughout the
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
28
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
project to provide staff with hands-on experience.)
Objective 5: The City has a performance measurement and management system that supports
the implementation of the strategic, operational, and financial goals and that provides key
indicators of progress so that elected officials, the public, and city managers will be able to track
progress and know how the City is performing.
Objective 6: The project is conducted using an approach that
• Is inclusive and is perceived as such so that the resulting plan has broad community support.
• Involves city staff as partners with consultants so that the planning cycle and system can be
sustained independent of external advisory or consulting support in the future.
C. The Work to be Done
GFOA will work with the City to accomplish the above objectives in eight phases, as is
described in greater detail later in this section. The key written deliverable of this project will be
a "Strategic Business Plan." The Strategic Business Plan will contain the highest priority
strategic issues facing the City, the strategies the City will pursue, and the actions it will take to
address these issues and their financial implications. The process for providing this deliverable
has three essential components:
• Strategic: What are the most important "big picture" strategic issues and concerns facing the
City over the long-term?
• Operational: What actions will the City take to address these issues? What is the schedule
for these activities? Who is responsible? How will progress be measured and accountability
maintained?
• Financial: What are the long -run financial implications of the strategic issues and
operational plans? How can the City maintain financial sustainability over the long-term?
Phase 1 — Project Start-up
Task A. Designate a Project Leader and Project Manager, and Define Project Success.
GFOA's experience is that this type of organization -wide project will require careful
coordination, communication, and cooperation, both between GFOA's team and City staff, as
well as among City agencies. Therefore, we strongly recommend that the City designate a
Project Leader who is committed to a successful project outcome and to addressing the issues
that prompted the City to initiate this project and who has the authority to make decisions
regarding the process. In addition, we recommend that the City identify a Project Manger to
coordinate the project on a day-to-day basis and serve as the City's liaison with the GFOA team.
Finally as part of this first task, GFOA has found that even though the City would execute a
formal contract with GFOA, it is extremely helpful to spend some time at the very beginning
defining and clarifying expectations regarding how the project will be conducted and the results
that the City hopes for and expects, and documenting these expectations so that they can be
referred to, and revised, if necessary, during the course of the project. This will help us to meet
your expectations.
=> Deliverable: A City -designated Project Leader and Project Manager, and a Project
Expectations Agreement (informal), which would be developed by GFOA and approved by
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
29
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
the Project Leader or other designated City staff. A formal project plan and timeline will
also be finalized at this point.
City Role: Coordinate meetings with GFOA, identify Project Leader and Manager, and
identify and agree on expectations for project success.
Task B. Establish a Project Steering Team and supporting teams. GFOA recommends that
the City designate a Project Steering Team (which will also serve as the City's Strategic
Planning Coordinating Team). The team will give feedback and guidance to GFOA and City
staff and provide continuity to carry over into implementation of the Strategic Business Plan.
GFOA will help the City develop requirements for team membership and write a charter to
clarify the Committee's responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources.
The Strategic Business Planning process is also likely to require supporting teams to
work on various issues and tasks associated with constructing a plan. GFOA will work with the
Project Leader and Project Manager to identify teams and advise on the knowledge, skills, and
ability needed by members.
=> Deliverable: Creation of a Project Steering Team and charter, as well as a structure of
supporting teams.
City Role: Coordinate meetings, approve the charter, agree on teams and name team
members.
Task C. Community Involvement Strategy. GFOA and the City will collaborate to develop a
community involvement strategy for the planning process. Community involvement is important
to ensure that planners consider a comprehensive set of issues, not just those identified by
"insiders" and to increase the likelihood of strong community support for the plan. The
community involvement strategy should include a timetable, mechanisms for community
involvement and communication, specific tools and techniques to involve the community, and a
strategy to engage the local media.
=> Deliverable: Community involvement strategy document.
=> City Role: Provide knowledge on the approaches that work best for the San Juan Capistrano
community and approve a process for going forward.
Phase 2 — Creating the Mission and Vision
Task A. Gather Stakeholder Input. GFOA will begin by interviewing key stakeholders, both
inside and outside of city government. City staff may wish to work with GFOA's team on these
interviews. GFOA will also work with the City to establish and approach and schedule for
conducting focus groups and phone surveys of constituents. GFOA's proposal assumes that
GFOA would help design the focus group approach and conduct a small number (no more than
four) of focus groups in cooperation with City staff. GFOA will also work with City staff to
design other stakeholder input opportunities, as identified in the community involvement
strategy.
Please note that because of the cost and intense resource requirement of conducting a
phone survey, GFOA's proposal andprice do not include this activity. Because this is not a core
capability of GFOA, we would have needed to include a sub -contractor to provide this service
and also the costs of GFOA administration and supervision of the sub -contract. We believe that
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 30
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
if the City decides a phone survey is essential to the process, having the City directly procure
telephone survey services would provide equal benefit at lower cost. We therefore assume that,
if the City and GFOA agree that phone surveys are needed, the City would contract separately
for this service.
=> Deliverable: A summary of information obtained from interviews, focus groups and other
stakeholder input mechanisms the City chooses to use (e.g., telephone surveys).
=:> City Role: Work together with GFOA to: define interviewees, schedule interviews, conduct
interviews (if desired by the City), and conduct focus groups. The City would also contract
for a phone survey if it is decided that one is needed, and conduct other stakeholder input
opportunities that may be identified in the public involvement strategy to be developed.
Task B. Mission and Vision Workshop. The GFOA will facilitate a public workshop to present
stakeholder input and develop a mission and vision statement. The mission and vision articulate
where the City wants to go and what it wants to become over the next five, 10, and 20 years. The
workshop will use consensus -driven techniques.
Deliverable: Provide workshop agendalstructure, conduct workshop, provide brief memo of
results.
=* City Role: Provide logistical support and coordination, and participate in
Phase 3 - Analysis
Task A. Financial Analysis. GFOA will conduct an analysis of the City's financial situation, at
minimum to include the following activities:
• Financial policies. GFOA will identify, catalog, and review the city's financial policies with
the assistance of City staff (particularly to identify existing policies).
• Preliminary Revenue/Expenditure Forecasting. GFOA will work with the City to develop
the "first cut" of a 20 -year forecast, based on status -quo assumptions. GFOA proposes to use
the Municast forecasting system.
• Debt Analysis. GFOA will conduct a high-level assessment of the City's current and likely
future debt position based on the City's capital improvement plan and information included
in the City's most recent comprehensive annual financial report.
• Imbalance Analysis. GFOA and City staff will identify potential future imbalances in the
City's financial and recommend strategies for overcoming these imbalances.
=> Deliverable: GFOA will lead the development of these analyses and will provide the results
in a Financial Analysis Report.
=> City Role: Provide information to GFOA to conduct analysis. Work closely with GFOA to
use the Municast system to make the forecast. Work with GFOA to identify imbalances and
to create mitigating strategies.
Task B. Environmental Analysis. GFOA will work with the City to conduct a comprehensive
environmental analysis to identify the most important issues facing the City of San Juan
Capistrano over a five-, 10-, and 20 -year period. In order to develop this list of issues, the
environmental scan will identify internal strengths and weaknesses and external threats and
opportunities, as well as community resources the City might take advantage of. The following
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 31
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
techniques will be used:
• GFOA will use information gleaned from stakeholder input activities described in Phase 2,
Task A above, and also conduct additional interviews as needed in order to assure broad
stakeholder input that includes, at minimum, the perspectives of City Council members, City
staff, members of boards and commissions, as well as stakeholders outside City government,
such as the business community, overlapping units of governments, citizen groups and
individual citizens.
• We will also review of other City plans such as land -use, redevelopment, and sewer -water
master plans, etc.
• We will conduct comparative analysis of financial condition indicators with other
municipalities (up to five). The comparative analysis will rely on "industry standard"
indicators of financial condition.
• The City and GFOA will construct a "fmancial trend monitoring system" of indicators to
reveal favorable and unfavorable trends in the financial environment.
=> Deliverable: An brief summary of the environmental analysis that contains key service,
financial, and other issues and the City's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and
challenges. This summary will also provide GFOA's recommendations on strategies the City
might pursue and new master plans that need to be developed in response to an issue.
City Role: Provide information to GFOA to conduct analysis, participate in various analytic
activities, and review and provide feedback on the summary document.
Phase 4 — Issues and Strategies Validation
Task A. Planning Retreat: GFOA will design and conduct a two-day workshop/retreat to
present a draft set of issues, as well as preliminary recommendations on strategies, overall
objectives and a first cut of an action plan, involving City staff on the first day and City Council
members and executives on the second day.
On the first day, in the morning, we will review the Environmental Analysis Report,
validate the report findings, and present preliminary issues, strategies, objectives and the outlines
of an action plan. In the afternoon, City staff will work in groups to validate, revise, and
supplement this information, as well as take the fust steps toward creating an action plan that
will later be used as the framework for the operations section of the Strategic Business Plan.
On the second day, GFOA will facilitate a workshop with the City Council and executive
staff. In the morning, GFOA will present information similar to that presented to City staff, with
the exception that this version will include staff input from the first day of the retreat. In the
afternoon we will facilitate a discussion focused on validating, revising, and supplementing the
key elements that will go into a written plan.
=> Deliverable: Documents, workshop facilitation, and presentations as well as retreat design
and a written summary of workshop output and outcomes.
=> City Role: Scheduling, coordination, invitations, and other workshop logistics as well as
participation. Work with GFOA to validate plan elements to date with Strategic Plan Steering
Committee.
Phase 5 — Business Planning and Performance Measurement
Task A. Template Development. Business planning describes implementation plans and
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
32
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
schedules, high-level financial impacts of strategic goals/action-plans, and performance
measures and other mechanisms for monitoring progress on implementing the pian. Business
planning also assesses risks inherent in the proposed course of action and identifies
contingencies. GFOA will develop and deliver a set of business planning and performance
measurement templates for City staff to help City staff develop the information required for a
business plan. The templates will be designed to produce an "issue driven" business plan, rather
than one focused on departments or other functional divisions of the City.
=> Deliverable: Business Plan templates delivered.
=> City Role: Review templates and begin to develop information required by templates in order
to prepare for Task B.
Task B. Business Planning & Performance Measurement Development. GFOA will work
with City staff to develop the business plan and performance measures. GFOA's and the City's
objective will be to train staff to create business plans. Another objective will be to develop a set
of strategic measures that communicates progress on strategic issues to elected officials, staff,
and the public. From these strategic measures, a larger set of operational measures will cascade
down to departmental operations. These operational measures will help departments to relate
their activities to the City's strategic goals and track their progress. City staff will also identify
performance targets based on the measures to help the City gauge its progress towards goals.
=> Deliverable: A workshop or other mechanism for developing business plans, performance
measures and targets.
=> City Role: Logistical support, participation in the process and completion of business plans.
Task C. Business Plan Consultation. It is unlikely that the Business Plan will be totally
complete at the end of the workshop or training sessions. City staff will have to refine and further
develop the plan as a result of what is discussed at the workshop. GFOA can make itself
available on a per -hour basis to provide consultation and staff augmentation to the City, as
required to support the completion of the business plan.
Deliverable: GFOA works with City to support the completion of the business plan for up to
15 consultant hours.
City Role: Make final decision on how GFOA's hours are to be used. Complete business
plans.
Phase 6 — Drafting the Strategic Business Plan
Task A. Committee Validation. A meeting will be held with the Strategic Plan Steering
Committee to review the materials and progress made to this point. The Committee's validation
will allow the Strategic Business Plan to be drafted.
Deliverable: Proposed outline for Strategic Business Plan provided. Meeting held to validate
direction and Strategic Business Plan contents.
=> City Role: Coordinate meeting, validate Plan contents.
Task B. Draft Plan. GFOA and City staff will cooperate to finalize a draft of the Strategic
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 33
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Business Plan. The Strategic Business Plan will be based on the strategic, operational, and
fmancial elements produced throughout the project.
=:> Deliverable: Strategic Business Plan draft created.
=> City Role: Participate in writing certain sections of the plan. There are some sections that
may require deeper City input and where hands-on experience is important for building staff
capacity to create new plans in the future.
Task C. Forecast Update. The information provided through the foregoing phase will enable
the City and GFOA to refine the forecast further. More in-depth information on the resource
requirements needed to put the Strategic Business Plan into operation will enable the City to
create more detailed spending scenarios. It is anticipated that the City will lead this forecast
update, but GFOA will advise how to best incorporate these scenarios into the Municast model.
=> Deliverable: Advise City on how to incorporate new information into Municast.
=> City Role: Update Municast model and make forecast.
Task D. Final Plan. After the draft plan is delivered, there will be a review and comment period
after which will be a public meeting to present the plan. GFOA will help the City design the
meeting and will participate in the meeting.
Deliverable: Public meeting held to present plan after the plan has received thorough review
and approval by appropriate City participants.
=> City Role: Coordinate meeting, help present plan.
Phase 7 - Linking to the Budget Process
Task A. Designing Link between Business Plan and Budget. The budget process is one of the
most important methods for executing the Strategic Business Plan. GFOA will work with City
staff on a process for assuring that the plan becomes the basis for the budget — or, at minimum, is
a critical input to the budgeting process.
=> Deliverable: GFOA works with City on a per -hour basis to advise on linkages, develop
forms, etc.
=> City Role: Respond to GFOA suggestions on how to use hours and otherwise approve how
hours will be used.
Phase 8 — Documentation and Wrap -Up
Task A. Project Review. Taking the time to reflect on the project and identify what aspects of
the project the City wants to save, delete, and change going forward is the first step towards
developing an on-going Strategic Business Planning cycle.
=> Deliverable: Review project with Strategic Plan Steering Committee.
=* City Role: Participate in meeting.
Task B. Develop On-going Strategic Business Plan Process. GFOA will propose a final on -
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 34
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The Citv of San Juan Capistrano
going Strategic Business Planning model for the City that can be maintained independent of
consultant support. The final recommended process will make use of the tools and techniques
used during this project, as well as lessons for how these tools and techniques can be better
adapted to the City's on-going use.
=> Deliverables: A process map to depict the final recommended process, including the links
into the budget process.
City Roles: Review and provide feedback on final process
Task C. Transitioning the Strategic Plan Steering Committee to Implementation. GFOA
will help the City transition the Committee's role to implementation. We will help the City
define the Committee's responsibility, accountability, authority, and resources for the
implementation of the plan.
=, Deliverables: A charter for the Steering Committee's implementation role.
=> City Roles: Participate in meeting to develop charter.
D. Out -of -Scope Activities
We believe that our proposal provides a comprehensive response to the City's RFP, however,
there are some activities that are not within the scope of proposal that the City should be aware
of.
• Community Surveys. GFOA does not conduct community surveys. GFOA recommends
that the City contract with a specialized survey firm for that service.
• Land -Use Planning. While GFOA understands that land -use planning is not in the scope of
the RFP, we understand that land -use is an important consideration for San Juan Capistrano.
GFOA is not a land -use planning firm. If expert input is needed on land -use GFOA
recommends that the City contract separately with the firm that normally supports its land -
use master planning or that internal land use planning staff provide expert knowledge. In our
experience, internal staff can fill this role by being integrated into the strategic business
planning team structure.
Section 3 - Timetable/Schedule of Required Tasks
Section 2 describes all key project tasks, deliverables for each phase, and the GFOA and City's
roles in each. The Gantt chart below describes the timeline for this project. Completing the
project in October of 2008 will allow the City to use the Strategic Business Plan as a lead-in to
its budget process. This should provide plenty of lead time for any more extensive budget
procedures that the City and GFOA deem necessary.
March Aoril Mav June July Aus Sent Oct
Phase 1. Proied Start -U
A. Designate Leader
B. Establish Teams
C. Involvement Strategy
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 35
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Phase 2. Create Mission/Vision
A. Stakeholder Input
B. Mission & Vision Workshop
Phase 3. Analysis
A. Financial Analysis
B. Environmental Analysis
Phase 4. Issues & Strategies Validation
A. Planning Retreat
Phase 5. Business Planning & Performance Measurement
A. Templates Developed
B. Plan & Measures Developed
C. Plan Consultation
Phase 6. Drafting the Plan
A. Committee Validation
B. Draft Plan
C. Forecast Update
D. Final Plan
Phase 7. Link to Budget
A. Designing Link
Phase 8. Documentation & Wrap U
A. Project Review
B. On -Going Planning Process
C. Transition to Implementation
Section 4 - Identify the Team
This section includes: A) The proposing firms; B) Contact information; C) Location of the work;
D) Organization chart; and E)Proposed team members.
A. The Proposing Firm
The GFOA is the primary proposing firm. The GFOA was established in 1906. It is the premier
professional association for government finance professionals in the United States and Canada
and has more than 17,500 members. As a non-profit educational organization, GFOA's mission
is to enhance and promote the professional management of governments for the public's benefit.
GFOA identifies and develops best practices in the area of long-range and strategic planning and
budgeting and promotes them through a national training program, books and other publications,
and an annual conference.
The Research and Consulting Center is GFOA's research and analysis and management
consulting division. The GFOA is nationally recognized for its comprehensive analytical and
advisory services, as well as for its practitioner -oriented research on issues related to stats and
local government finance. GFOA staff work closely with practitioners to develop and
disseminate recommended practices in all of the functional areas of public finance. In addition,
the GFOA publishes books and periodicals, and coordinates GFOA's national training program
and annual conference.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 36
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Since beginning operations in 1977, the Research and Consulting Center has undertaken
hundreds of projects with state and local governments, federal agencies, and private sector
clients. The GFOA provides financial and management consulting services in the areas of
strategic planning, long-term financial planning, performance measurement, debt capacity
analysis, multi-year budgeting, and operational reviews, among others.
GFOA is partnering with the Government Finance Research Group to provide the
Municast financial forecasting software model. The Municast solution is 1001/6 based on
Microsoft Excel and will not require the City to purchase any new software from GFOA or the
Government Finance Research Group. Municast is currently in use by over 20 California
municipalities.
B. Contact Information
The primary contact for this proposal is Anne Spray Kinney, the Director of the GFOA Research
and Consulting Center (RCC). Anne can be reached at 312-917-6102 or at akinneyAgfoa.org.
The secondary contact for this project is Shayne Kavanagh, Senior Manager of Research for the
GFOA RCC. He can be reached at 312-578-2276 or at skavanagh(ofog a.ora.
C. Location of the Work
GFOA proposes a combination of on -sits work at the City's premises and off-site work at GFOA
and Municast offices. GFOA offices are located in Chicago. Government Finance Research
Group offices are located in San Juan Capistrano.
D. Organization Chart
GFOA proposes that the City's Strategic Plan Steering Committee play an overall governance
role, while the project leader acts as the official engagement manager. GFOA also proposes that
the City set up a parallel team structure to GFOA's team, including a project coordinator who
will handle many of the day -today activities of the project. The City's team would be supervised
by the City's coordinator but both the coordinator and the City's teams would have a great deal
of interaction with GFOA's team as they work together on the planning process. We believe this
structure will provide valuable hands-on experience for the City. Please note that the final
structure and names of the City's teams would be determined jointly with the City.
Strategic Plan Steering Canrnittee
City's Project Leader
Strategic &
GFOA Financial
FOA Strategic
Business Plan
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
37
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
E. Proposed Team Members
GFOA assigns a small group of highly qualified individuals to consulting projects it undertakes.
Nearly all of GFOA's consultants have worked as managers in local government or hold
advanced degrees in public policy or administration. All of our project managers have worked as
government managers. GFOA's staff of professionals is directly involved in GFOA's continuing
professional education programs (some as instructors), including national training seminars and
the annual conference. Government finance is our business, and our consultants are eminently
qualified to perform the type of work the City is requesting. Below are our proposed staff
members. Complete bios for our team are available in "Section 5 - Qualifications and Related
Experience."
Project Role
Team Member Name
Project Manager
Anne Spray Kinney
Strategic & Business Plan Manager
Steve Kreklow
Financial Planning Manager
Shayne Kavanagh
Facilitation Assistance
David Burna
Lead Strategic/Business Plan Analyst
John Ruggini
Strategic/Business Plan Analyst
Christine Lambino
Strategic/Business Plan Analyst
Mike Mucha
Financial Plan Analyst
Brenda Boyle
Municast Configuration
Chris Swanson
Anne Kinney and Shayne Kavanagh are the team principles. Their contact information was
provided earlier in this section.
Section 5 - Qualifications and Related Experience
This section includes: A) GFOA's strategic and financial planning expertise; B) Recent directly
related experience; C) Key personnel who will be involved in the project; D) Other public
entities to which we have provided services.
A. GFOA's Strategic and Financial Planning Expertise
GFOA's team for this project has long-term experience developing governmental strategic plans
and financial plans. Anne Spray Kinney and Stephen Kreklow, senior team members on this
project, have worked both as government practitioners and consultants with state, regional, and
local governments to create integrated strategic planning -performance measurement -budgeting
systems and also have developed strategic plans and implementation plans for sub -organizational
systems, such as performance measurement and management systems and large organizational
re -designs.
GFOA's experience and resources in performance measurement and management are
equally strong, based on the experience of team members, GFOA's research, and its ability to
call on its membership base for examples of high quality processes and documents.
GFOA's expertise in financial planning for local government is unsurpassed. We have
been providing consulting on long-term financial planning since 2001 and we have published the
leading book on the topic, Financing the Future: Long -Term Financial Planning for Local
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 38
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
Government. Shayne Kavanagh, the author of this book, is a senior member of our proposed
project team. We have been invited to speak on financial planning at the annual conferences for
the International City/County Management Association, that National League of Cities, as well
as a number of state -level organizations including the California Society of Municipal Finance
Officers. We have also published articles on financial planning in leading journals such as
Government Finance Review, Public Management, and School Business Affairs.
GFOA is constantly honing our expertise on this topic as well. We maintain a Web site
dedicated to financial planning at www.pfoa.org/ltfn, which is regularly updated with new
resources. We are currently working with the National League of Cities to conduct research
designed to deepen our understanding of how elected officials can participate in financial
planning and plan to publish a new book on the subject in the early summer of 2008.
B. Recent Directly Related Experience
Below are our recent directly related experiences. Those experiences that we believe will be of
most interest to the City are presented first.
Milwaukee (Wisconsin) Public Schools
• Description of Work: Performance Measurement and Budgeting, including identification of
strategic objectives and long-range strategies (derived from previous MPS planning
processes), performance measures, annual targets, and a performance-based budget within
in a linked system. GFOA worked with the school district administration to identify district -
wide long-term outcomes and strategies derived from previous planning efforts to guide
development of performance measures and an annual performance budget, and then assisted
the District to develop a performance-based budget. GFOA also provided training, meeting
facilitation, and coaching to departmental managers, as well as a performance measurement
and budgeting handbook.
• Primary Client Contact: Michelle Nate, CFO, Milwaukee Public Schools, (414) 475-
8336, natemi mail.milwaukee.k]2.wi.us.
• Dates for Project: October 2006 to present.
• Project Manager: Stephen Kreklow
• Members of Team on Project: Anne Kinney, Steve Kreklow, Mike Mucha, Christine
Lambino
• Project Costs: $150,280
City of Gresham, Oreton
• Description of Work: Long-term financial planning advisory services, including a debt
affordability analysis and peer group analysis.
• Primary Client Contact:
o Terry McCall, Finance and Management Services Director, (503) 618-2372,
Terry. McCall ,ci.gresham.or.us, 1333 NW Eastman Pkwy, Gresham, OR 97030
o Deborah Bond, Acting Finance Director, (503) 618-2855,
Deborah. Bondaa ci.gresham.or.us, 1333 NW Eastman Pkwy, Gresham, OR 97030
• Dates for Project: GFOA first worked with Gresham in 2001. In this project, GFOA took
the lead role in developing the plan. Gresham in late 2006 sought to refresh the plan but this
time GFOA took a more hands-off advisory role, while Gresham did most of the work. With
GFOA's guidance they completed a new plan in 2007.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 39
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
• Name of Project Manager: Shayne Kavanagh (both in 2001 and 2007)
• Members of Team on Project: Shayne Kavanagh, project manager, Steve Kreklow, Lead
Analyst, Anne Kinney, Engagement Manager
• Project Costs: 2001 - $47,500; 2006/07 - $25,000
City of Montclair, California
• Description of Work: Long-term financial planning advisory services, including
development of multi-year strategic business plan.
• Primary Client Contact: Edward Starr, Director of Administrative Services, (909) 625-
9405, ecstarr@ci.montclair.ca.us, 5111 Benito Street, Montclair, CA 91763
• Dates for Project: GFOA fust worked with Montclair in 2001. The City was very pleased
with strategic planning and has asked GFOA back every summer since, with our most recent
engagement completing in 2007.
• Name of Project Manager: Shayne Kavanagh (starting in 2001 and each year since)
• Members of Team on Project: Shayne Kavanagh, Anne Kinney, Engagement Manager
• Project Costs: 2001 - $35,000; average cost for annual engagements $10,000.
City of San Clemente, California
• Description of Work: Assist the City with refining its financial planning process to better
engage elected officials in the process.
• Primary Client Contact: Pall Gudgeirsson, Treasurer/Assistant City Manager, (949) 361-
$341, GUdgeirssonPna,san-Clemente.org, 100 Avenida Presidio, San Clemente, CA 92672
• Dates for Project: GFOA commenced and completed this project in late 2007.
• Name of Project Manager: Shayne Kavanagh
• Members of Team on Project: Shayne Kavanagh, project manager, lead analyst
• Project Costs: $2,000
C. Key Personnel
Below are the key personnel on the GFOA team and their biographies.
Anne Spray Kinney is Director of the Research and Consulting Center of the Government
Finance Officers Association. Ms. Kinney has more than 20 years' experience in local
government, much of it as a practitioner. Before becoming a consultant, Ms. Kinney served as
budget director and subsequently administration director for the City of Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
and was the executive director of Milwaukee's regional flood control -water reclamation
authority in addition to other management positions in state and local government. Before
coming to GFOA, Ms. Kinney was a Senior Partner at the Public Strategies Group. Ms. Kinney
has managed a broad array of organizational improvement efforts, and has conducted numerous
strategic planning -budgeting -performance measurement processes and organizational
assessments at the city, county and state government level. Ms. Kinney has designed and
implemented integrated planning -performance measurement budgeting systems, information
technology strategy, customer service and compliance plans; procurement and contracting plans
and systems, and government -wide managed competition programs. Ms. Kinney has also
conducted projects focused on human resource services, revenue enhancement, business process
improvement, and intergovernmental service sharing. In addition to consulting, Ms. Kinney is a
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 40
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
frequent presenter on these topics to national audiences and has published articles on strategic
planning, results budgeting, performance management, privatization and outsourcing, and
leadership in the public sector and has taught government financial management at the graduate
level. Ms. Kinney holds a BA from American University and an MPA from the University of
Illinois -Chicago.
Steven R Kreklow has more than 15 years experience as a manager in local government.
Before joining GFOA he was the Budget Director and Human Resources Manager for
Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District and previously served as Finance & Planning
Manager for the city of Milwaukee's Department of Public Works. In addition he has served as
an operations manager for municipal services as diverse as parking and forestry. While at the
Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District, Steve was responsible for strategic and long-term
financial planning and development of the operating budget and capital improvements program
as well as directing internal analysis on the financing of the District's 2020 Facilities
Improvement Plan. GFOA's Distinguished Budget Presentation Award Program recognized two
of the budget documents prepared under Mr. Kreklow's direction for "Outstanding Use of
Performance Measures." His clients include Genesee County, Michigan and the City of
Milwaukee Department of Public Works where he was the project manager for a strategic
planning process. He was also project manager for performance measurement system
development projects at Sacramento County, California, and Milwaukee Public Schools and was
a key project team member on long -tern financial planning projects in Gresham, Oregon, and
Rialto, California. Mr. Kreklow consults, researches, and trains in the areas of strategic planning,
budgeting, financial management, performance measurement, technology, and organizational
development. He also regularly teaches government finance courses for universities and
continuing education programs in the Milwaukee area. Mr. Kreklow holds a Master of Public
Administration from the University of Wisconsin -Milwaukee.
Shayne Kavanagh is the Senior Manager of Research for GFOA. Mr. Kavanagh has worked on
a number of strategic planning and long-term planning projects. He served as the project
manager for projects at the City of Montclair, California, the City of Gresham, Oregon, the City
of Rialto, California, and the City of San Clemente, California Mr. Kavanagh has authored the
GFOA publications Financing the Future: Long -Term Financial Planning for Local Government
and Financial Policies: Design and Implementation. He has spoken on the topic of financial
planning and policies at the California Society of Municipal Finance Officers, the New England
States GFOA, the Michigan Government Finance Officers Association, the International
City/County Management Association, National League of Cities, and GFOA annual conference.
He has written articles on financial planning that have appeared in journals such as Government
Finance Review, Public Management, and School Business Affairs. Prior to joining GFOA, Mr.
Kavanagh was the Assistant Village Manager for the Village of Palos Park, Illinois. Mr.
Kavanagh graduated from with his MPA degree from Northern Illinois University where he was
the ASPA student of the year for his graduating class.
David Burna is a Senior Manager in the GFOA Research and Consulting Center. Mr. Buma
specializes in the development and implementation of strategic planning and change
management projects. Mr. Bursa specializes in facilitation, business process re-engineering, and
decision analysis for government. Mr. Buma has conducted business process mapping,
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 41
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
evaluation, and re-engineering efforts for the numerous clients. Recent projects include: City of
Overland Park (KS); City of Newport News (VA); City of Topeka (KS); City of Raleigh (NC);
and County of Marin (CA). Mr. Buma has an MPP in Environmental Policy from Harvard
University's John F. Kennedy School of Government. Mr. Buma has worked with both private
firms and public agencies on a wide variety of strategic planning projects. He has helped clients
to manage stakeholder involvement, public relations, investment strategies, and mergers &
acquisitions. Mr. Buma has developed training courses for technical and public sector
professionals looking to enhance both their facilitation and long-range planning skills. He has
implemented long-range planning solutions for institutions as diverse as the South Florida Water
Management District (SFWMD), Department of Energy (DoE), Chevron Pipeline, City of New
York - Parks & Recreation Department, Los Angeles Department of Public Works - Bureau of
Sanitation, and the New York City Department of Environmental Protection.
John Ruggini is a Manager with the GFOA and works extensively in the area of performance
measurement. He manages the research for the State and Local Government Performance
Measurement Sourcebook (to be published in spring 2008). He has conducted research on
budget and performance measurement systems for San Luis Obispo County and provided
consulting assistance to the City and County of San Francisco for a budget and performance
measurement system. Mr. Ruggini also led the development of GFOA's toolkit to help local
governments understand and manage their `other post -employment benefit" (OPEB) liabilities.
Before joining GFOA, he worked in the City Administrator's office at the City of St. Charles,
Illinois where he served as the primary coordinator for the performance measurement program in
conjunction with the International City/County Managers Association's (ICMA) Center for
Performance Measurement. He also conducted annual assessments of financial trends, which
included benchmarked ratio analysis of the City's financial condition and assisted with the
development of departmental business plans. Mr. Ruggini received his MPA from Northern
Illinois University.
Mike Mucha is a Consultant/Analyst with the GFOA and focuses on management and
technology research and consulting. He researches local governments' use of performance
measures and coordinates all GFOA training sessions on performance measurement and
budgeting. Mr. Mucha has worked with the Milwaukee Public School District to implement
performance-based budgeting and was involved with creating a performance measurement
guidebook for Sacramento County. Mr. Mucha co -edited GFOA's recent publication: Capital
Project Planning and Evaluation. Prior to coming to GFOA, Mr. Mucha worked with the Sports
& Exhibition Authority of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County. He received a Master of Science in
Public Policy and Management from the Heinz School of Public Policy and Management at
Carnegie Mellon University.
Brenda Boyle is a Consultant/Policy Analyst in the GFOA. Ms. Boyle is heavily involved in
GFOA's long-term financial planning program. She has developed GFOA's training course on
financial planning, conducted case -study research, and provided consulting services. She has
also conducted extensive research on use of performance measurement and strategic planning at
the state level for GFOA's upcoming Performance Measurement Sourcebook publication. She
has also participated in a performance-based budgeting consulting project for Genesee County,
Michigan. Ms. Boyle received an MPA with concentration in Public Financial Administration
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
42
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
from Indiana University's School of Public & Environmental Affairs.
Christine Lambino is a Consultant/Analyst with the GFOA. Ms. Lambino has worked with
Milwaukee Public School District and Genesee County, Michigan, to implement performance-
based budgeting. Ms. Lambino also assists with research related to government use of
performance measures and budgeting for outcomes. Prior to working at GFOA, Ms. Lambino
held positions in local governments including King County, Washington, and the Village of
Wilmette, Illinois. Ms. Lambino holds an MPA from Northwestern University.
Christopher J. Swanson is the founder of Government Finance Research Group (GFRG), a
financial management consulting firm specializing in financial planning, research, cost analysis,
econometric modeling, benchmarking and optimization modeling for local governments throughout
the U.S. Chris developed an innovative financial forecasting and analysis model called, MuniCast®.
Municast is in use by over 20 cities across California. Chris' background includes 20 years of
government and corporate financial management, including senior financial and strategic planning
roles at the City of Los Angeles, United Healthcare Systems, HealthNet and The Walt Disney
Company. Chris has developed complex economic and financial models, implemented performance
measurement systems and led process improvement initiatives at public and private sector
organizations. His academic credentials include an MBA from UCLA's Anderson Graduate School
of Management and BA in Political Science from California State University, Northridge. GFRG is a
sole proprietorship based in California.
D. Other Public Entities Served
GFOA has provided consulting services to over 100 public entities. Section 5-B describes those
of greatest relevance to this project.
Section 6 - Other Information
A. Optional Services
This section describes services that could enhance the City's planning process, but that GFOA
does not believe are essential based on the City's RFP.
Additional Focus Group/Interview Support. GFOA can conduct additional focus groups /
interviews over what our proposal assumes.
Additional Support in Other Areas. Our approach places progressively greater responsibility
on the City staff for to improve the City's ability to plan after the GFOA's engagement is
completed. GFOA is happy to provide deeper support and take a more hands-on role if the City
prefers.
Municast Customization. Additional features can be added to Municast on a per -hour
consultative basis. The City will receive the new "all funds" version of Municast which includes
a great number of new features. As such, it is unlikely that the City will need to perform
additional customization.
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA 43
GFOA's Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business Plan Proposal for
The City of San Juan Capistrano
B. About Our Discount
GFOA conducts consulting engagements as part of our mission of identifying, helping to
develop, and broadly disseminating best practices in governmental management. Because of the
comprehensive nature of this project we believe that the results are likely to contribute to "best
practices" that can be shared with other governments. GFOA is therefore pleased to be able to
provide a 15% discount on our fees.
C. Key Assumptions
• City staff provides data and participates in interview and other activities requested by GFOA.
• A single point of contact from the City is identified;
• GFOA undertakes no more than the indicated number of on-site trips within the price
included in this proposal.
o Trip #1 - Interview stakeholders on defining success and perception of environment,
meeting with Strategic Plan Steering Committee, conduct technical planning
workshops (forecasting, environmental modeling, etc.). 3 days, 2 people
o Trip #2 — Conduct focus groups, 2 days, 2 people
o Trip #3 — Conduct mission workshop, 1 day, 2 people
o Trip #4 — Strategic issues retreat, 2 days, 2 people
o Trip #5 — Business plan workshop 2 days, 2 people
o Trip #6 — Present draft plan to committee 1 day, 2 people
o Trip #7 — Present draft plan to public 1 day, 2 people
• GFOA's role in the development of a plan is consultative and advisory in nature. The City
will play an important role in data collection, participating as partners in plan development,
and will make any final decisions on strategy and direction.
• The project scope is not expanded beyond the items listed in the proposal at the proposed
(discounted) price, unless so negotiated with the GFOA.
• As an educational, nonprofit, professional membership association, GFOA reserves the right
to publish non -confidential documents describing the results of, or created during, the
services described in this scope of work. GFOA will not publish any item with the name of
the City of San Juan Capistrano without obtaining prior written consent of the government.
• GFOA develops its reports to be clear and concise. We focus on brevity in order to make our
reports accessible to the public and elected officials.
• GFOA is a non-profit membership association made up of members like the City of San Juan
Capistrano and therefore we have no owners' equity to fall back on. Therefore, GFOA's
liability and indemnification under any agreement reached with the City must be limited to
the extent of fees paid by GFOA's insurance coverage. (Please note that this limitation would
require an amendment to the City's standard Personal Services Agreement.)
Proprietary and Confidential to GFOA
44
EXHIBIT "C"
Revised Contract Fee
The fee would be payable in stages as shown below. We estimate travel expenses based on 9
trips as shown in "Exhibit A - Statement of Work - Long -Term Vision and Strategic Business
Planning City of San Juan Capistrano."
Phase
#R
Project stane
payn"M
porneet
Type
Phase
1
Start-up activities and Phase 1 deliverables
provided to City
10,030
Fixed
Phase
2
Phase 2 deliverables provided to City
(except focusgroup)
13,090
Fixed
Phase
2
Focus group deliverable completed
12,500
Fixed
Phase
3
Phase 3 deliverables provided to City
10,030
Fixed
Phase
4
Phase 4 deliverables provided to City
8,075
Fixed
Phase
4
Focus oroup deliverable completed
12,500
Fixed
Phase
5
Business planning templates and workshop
completed
8,075
Fixed
Phase
5
Business plan consultation completed
1,870
Fixed
Phase
6
Strategic Business Plan presented
4,250
Fixed
Phase
7
Budget linkage designed
4,250
Fixed
Phase
8
Phase 8 deliverables provided to City
3,060
Fixed
Travel
Travel Estimate
15,000
Not -to -Exceed
TOTAL
102,730
GFOA's standard rates range from $250/hour for Senior Staff to $175 for Consultant Analysts.